McKinney v. Herrick
Cases that cite this one
28 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Christensen v. Harris (Iowa 1920)
- United States v. Tholen (District Court, N.D. Iowa 1960)
- Conrad v. Farmers Mutual Hail Insurance (Iowa 1937)
- Sturm v. Lloyd (Neb. 1936)
- Lundean v. Hamilton (Iowa 1918)
- Deming Investment Co. v. Wallace (Kan. 1906)
- Fritz v. Fritz (Minn. 1905)
- Burnes v. Burnes (U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western Missouri 1904)
- Bannister v. McIntire (Iowa 1900)
- Crum v. McCollum (Iowa 1930)
- State Savings Bank v. Deal (Iowa 1925)
- Betz v. Swanson (Iowa 1925)
- Midland Mortgage Co. v. Rice (Iowa 1924)
- Joseph v. Mangos (Iowa 1921)
- Lillie v. Shriver (Iowa 1920)
- Pels v. Stevens (Iowa 1919)
- Blossi v. Chicago & Northwestern Railway Co. (Iowa 1909)
- Mower Harwood Creamery & Dairy Supply Co. v. Hill (Iowa 1907)
- Holmes v. Baker (Iowa 1905)
- Stoner v. Zacharay (Iowa 1904)
- James & Haverstock v. Dalbey (Iowa 1899)
- Bonnot Co. v. Newman Bros. (Iowa 1899)
- Sutton v. Risser (Iowa 1898)
- Reid, Murdock & Co. v. Bradley (Iowa 1898)
- Jenkins v. Clyde Coal Co. (Iowa 1891)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
“Established 1849. The North American Lightning-Bod Oo. Order for Erection of Conductors.
“It is agreed that, after the erection or delivery of rods, this order is negotiable.
“Mr. L. Knight, Agt. for II. McKinney — Sir: Erect (or deliver) at your earliest convenience, on my house, a system of circuit conductors (three points and two rods to the ground) of the Star lightning-rod, in a proper and substantial manner, in accordance with scientific rules, and I will pay for the same on completion of work in cash, or note due June 6, 1885, at the rate of 67-|- cents per foot for the rods, $3.50 for each point, and the price of five feet of rod for each galvanized brace, $7 for each horse, rooster, or points of compass, $5 for each arrow, and $3 for each ball.
“It is expressly understood by the signer of this order that he signs the same upon his own judgment, after due deliberation by him, without any undue influence having been used, or relying on representations made by any agents other than written or printed on this order. In case of default in settlement as indicated above, when this order is filled, I agree to pay the amount at Ida Grove, Iowa. No charge for guaranty. Discount, $9.58. To use three j>oints, three balls, one arrow. Alpha Herrick.”
“Dated on June 6, 1884.
The amount sought to be recovered is $199.64, with interest from the date of the contracts. The defendant sought to reform them on' the ground that the true contract was not stated in the writings, and that they had been obtained by fraud and misrepresentation. But it was conceded that the
The rule is well settled that all oral representations and inducements which precede or are contemporaneous with the written contract are merged therein, unless such representations amount, under well-established rules of law, to fraud, which has the effect to avoid the written contract. Such representations are material only for such purpose. It is not stated in the answer that any misrepresentation was made as to the contents of the writing. The statements in the answer amount only to this: that the agent of the plaintiff represented that he had knowledge and experience as to the cost of lightning-rods, the mode and manner of putting them on buildings, and the expense of so doing. But he made no representations as to the price per foot, or as to the quantity or number of feet that would be required, other or different from the statements contained in the written contract. The defend • ant did not know how many rods or feet would be required, and in this respect it is stated in the answer that the plaintiff’s agent made fraudulent misrepresentations; but it is not claimed that under the written contracts the plaintiff is not entitled to recover the amount claimed.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.