City of Newton v. Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific R'y Co.
Cases that cite this one
10 later published cases cite this decision.
- Martin v. Carter (U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Montana 1891)
- First Trust Joint Stock Land Bank v. Cuthbert (Iowa 1933)
- City of Iola v. Missouri Pacific Railway Co. (Kan. 1916)
- Minneapolis, St. Paul, Rochester & Dubuque Electric Traction Co. v. City of Minneapolis (Minn. 1914)
- State ex rel. City of Duluth v. Northern Pacific Railway Co. (Minn. 1906)
- Wetherbee v. Michigan Central Railroad (Mich. 1899)
- Abbott v. Doane (Mass. 1895)
- City of Fort Dodge v. Minneapolis & St. Louis Railway Co. (Iowa 1893)
- Nicks v. Chicago, St. Paul & Kansas City Railway Co. (Iowa 1891)
- Dorsett v. Garrard (Ga. 1890)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
“ Sec. 1262. Any corporation may raise or lower any turnpike, plank-road or other highway, for the purpose of having its railway cross over or under the same; and in such cases said corporation shall put such highway, as soon as may be, in as good repair and condition as before such alteration.
“ Sec. 1263. If the supervisors, trustees, city council, or other person having jurisdiction over such highway, require further or different repairs or alterations made thereon, or if the same, in their opinion, is unsafe, they shall give notice thereof in writing to any agent or officer of the corporation, and, if the parties are unable to agree respecting the same, either party may apply by petition, setting out the facts, to the circuit court or judge thereof, and such court or judge shall cause reasonable notice to be given to the adverse party of the application. The petition shall be filed in the clerk’s office, and may be answered as in other cases. The court shall determine the matter in a summary way, and make the necessary orders in relation thereto, giving such corporation a reasonable time to comply therewith; and, upon failure to do so, said court may enjoin the corporation from using so much of its road as interferes with any such highway.”
The defendant’s position is that a literal compliance with the statute is impracticable; that an approximate compliance is all that is required; and that as to what would have been a sufficient compliance might be a question upon which there might be a difference of opinion; and that, such being the case, it was competent for the city to stipulate for a particular kind of crossing, and, in consideration of getting it, to impose upon itself some burden in respect to it. But, in our opinion, the position is not sound. We are unable to see.how, under the evidence, there could have been a bona fide claim that an overhead crossing was unnecessary; and, if it be conceded that it was necessary, there was no room for any dispute about the statutory obligation to put the street in as good repair and condition as it was before the railroad was built, if it could be done, and if not, then as nearly so as practicable; and that involved the doing of more than the defendant did. In our opinion the judgment of the circuit court must be
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.