Clayton v. Chicago, Iowa & Dakota R'y Co.
Cases that cite this one
13 later published cases cite this decision.
- State v. Papst (Iowa 1936)
- Matoza v. Southern Pacific Co. (Cal. Ct. App. 1922)
- Lithgow v. Pearson (Colo. App. 1913)
- Lithgow v. Pearson (Colo. App. 1913)
- Dethample v. Lake Koen Navigation, Reservoir & Irrigation Co. (Kan. 1906)
- Schevers v. American Railway Express Co. (Iowa 1923)
- Draker v. Iowa Electric Co. (Iowa 1921)
- Wrede v. Grothe (Iowa 1918)
- Adamson v. Harper (Iowa 1913)
- Lewis v. Omaha & Council Bluffs Suburban Railway Co. (Iowa 1912)
- Clark v. Wabash Railroad (Iowa 1906)
- Smith v. Hall (Iowa 1897)
- Railway v. Combs (Ark. 1888)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
That a railroad right of way is an easement, and that the fee remains in the owner of the land condemned for railway purposes, are correct as abstract propositions of law, but they have no application in proceedings to condemn land for right of way for a railroad, except when it is made to appear that the fee burdened with the easement is of some determinative value. The theory is that the easement is to be a perpetual right, and it is the usual practice to introduce evidence in these cases, showing the full value of the land actually taken, as an item in the estimate of the damages sustained by the property owner. This is allowed upon the theory that any interest he has in the land actually appropriated is of no value. This court has held that it is not error to refuse to instruct the jury in such eases that the fee title remains in the owner. Cummins v. Des Moines & St. Louis R’y Co., 63 Iowa, 397; Hollingsworth v. Same, Id., 443. And the jury are not warranted in estimating the compensation to
III. It is claimed that the compensation awarded by the jury is excessive. We think otherwise. The verdict appears to be fairly sustained by the evidence.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.