In re Assignment of Guyer
Cases that cite this one
7 later published cases cite this decision.
- Reynolds v. Black (Iowa 1894)
- Home State Bank v. Hunkey (Colo. 1917)
- Woonsocket Rubber Co. v. Falley (U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Indiana 1887)
- Kelly v. T. J. Ryan & Son (Iowa 1908)
- In re Assignment of Windhorst (Iowa 1898)
- Lacey v. Newcomb (Iowa 1895)
- Re Assignment of Pendleton Hardware Co. (Or. 1893)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
III. It is urged that the agreement between the assignor and Atwell for the execution of the mortgage can have no force and effect, and can give Atwell no right, for the reason that it is without consideration. The ready answer to this objection is that the consideration of the debt was the consideration of the agreement, just as it was of the note which was given for the debt. The note was given as a security for the debt; so was the mortgage. The agreement looked to the giving and perfecting of security, and this consideration of the debt was the consideration of all these contracts for its security. Because the agreement was not performed when made, at the time the debt was contracted, it is not, therefore, invalid, as being without consideration.
IY. In the case at bar the parties agreed, when the debt was contracted, that the mortgage should be executed upon the happening of a specified event, and should cover property specifically named. The event happened, and the mortgage was then executed. The law will presume that the mortgagee assented to the mortgage. Indeed, the finding of the agreement establishes the assent without the aid of pre
Y. The mortgagor having, by agreement, bound jbimself to execute the mortgage, and the mortgagee having assented thereto and agreed to accept it, the mortgagor would be authorized to file it for record, and the person to whom he delivered it was authorized to do 'this for him as his agent. The deposit of the mortgage in the recorder’s office operated as a delivery to the mortgagee.
YI. It will be observed that, in our view, the case wholly turns upon tbe fact that the execution and delivery of the mortgage was in pursuance of and compliance with a sufficient prior agreement between the parties. It therefore becomes unnecessary to consider positions of counsel upon other questions.
The judgment of the circuit court is Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.