Kirk v. St. Thomas' Church
Cases that cite this one
7 later published cases cite this decision.
- United States v. 329.22 Acres of Land, More or Less (United States District Court for the Middle District of Florida 1968)
- In re Cooper (Iowa 1940)
- Augustine v. Linn County (Iowa 1940)
- Berger v. University of New Mexico (N.M. 1923)
- Nugent v. Dilworth (Iowa 1895)
- Foy v. Coe College (Iowa 1895)
- Lacy v. Davis (Iowa 1900)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
I. The defendant is a religious society. The property in question was conveyed to it by way of gift many
II. At-the time of the sale plaintiff was a minor. E. R. Kirk, his father, was deputy treasurer of the county. He
Section 885 of the Code is as follows: “If any county treasurer or auditor shall hereafter be either directly or indirectly concerned in the purchase of any real property sold for the payment of taxes, he shall be liable to a penalty of not more than one thousand dollars, * * * and all such sales shall be void.”
The important question in the case is whether the deputy treasurer was concerned in the purchase, within the meaning
The object of the legislature in enacting the statute undoubtedly was to secure perfect fairness in the conduct of the sale. The public officers who are charged with the duty of conducting or aiding in the sale are not only prohibited from acquiring any interest in the property sold, but are forbidden to be in any manner concerned in the purchase of such property. That an officer may be concerned in the purchase, without himself acquiring any interest in the property sold, is very clear. If E. R. Kirk had himself bid in the property for plaintiff, and paid over the money to the treasurer, there could be no question, under the doctrine of the cases cited above, that the sale would be invalid. The fact that he was to receive no compensation for his services would make no difference; for the sale is invalid, not because of the fact merely that the officer has made a profit out of the purchase, but for the reason that, as he acted as the representative of the purchaser, he is presumed to have conducted the sale with reference to the interest of his principal, rather than with that perfect fairness and impartiality that the law requires; and it appears to us that the case is in precisely the condition it would have occupied if he had personally bid in the property. In making the bid, McFaul acted under .his direction and for his accommodation. He was but an instrument made use of by E. R. Kirk in effecting the purchase. When he announced that he would take the lot for .the amount of the taxes and costs due upon it, he but announced Kirk’s will with reference to the matter. It was .but .the announcement of Kirk’s bid upon the property, and
ReVBRSRT).
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.