City of Waterloo v. Union Mill Co.
Cases that cite this one
34 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- State Ex Rel. Schlegel v. Munn (Iowa 1933)
- Rohrig v. Whitney (Iowa 1944)
- Kelroy v. City of Clear Lake (Iowa 1942)
- Great Western Insurance v. Saunders (Iowa 1937)
- Wall v. Salt Lake City (Utah 1917)
- City of Huron v. Bank of Volga (S.D. 1896)
- Schwartz v. Wapello County (Iowa 1929)
- Perley v. Heath (Iowa 1926)
- Shultz v. City of Oskaloosa (Iowa 1922)
- Brightman v. Hetzel (Iowa 1918)
- Board of County Commissioners v. City of Lawrence (Kan. 1918)
- Kuehl v. Town of Bettendorf (Iowa 1917)
- Town of Kenwood Park v. Leonard (Iowa 1916)
- Christopherson v. Incorporated Town (Iowa 1916)
- Louden v. Starr (Iowa 1915)
- Keola v. Parker (Haw. 1913)
- Gable v. City of Cedar Rapids (Iowa 1911)
- Quinn v. Baage (Iowa 1907)
- Biglow v. Ritter (Iowa 1906)
- Burroughs v. City of Cherokee (Iowa 1906)
- Vorhes v. Incorporated Town of Ackley (Iowa 1905)
- Markham v. City of Anamosa (Iowa 1904)
- Weber v. City of Iowa City (Iowa 1903)
- City of Keokuk v. Cosgrove (Iowa 1902)
- Fountain v. Keen (Iowa 1902)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
—I. The defendant owns and operates a mill in the city of Waterloo. The race sujrplying the water used as motor-power for the mill was constructed about twentyyears ago, and occupies a part of Cedar street. At the westerly end of the street the race occupies nearly its whole width; but, running at an acute angle with the line of the street, the race leaves it about one hundred feet from its westerly end, thus occupying a part of the street in an angular form. The race‘being uncovered at the place, the street there cannot be used by the public. The plaintiff, in its petition, alleges that the race, so far as it occupies Cedar street, is a nuisance, and prays that defendant be, by a proper decree, required to abate it, either by removing the race, or by covering it in such manner that it shall not interfere with the use of the street. The defendant, as defenses, pleads (1) that the action is barred by the statate of limitations; (2) that Gedar street as platted was never accepted, occupied, used or improved, and it therefore never became a public street; and (3) that, after its dedication by platting, defendant’s grantor entered upon and constructed the race under a color of title and right, and made other valuable improve-
II. In our opinion, the right of the plaintiff and of the public to the use and occupancy of the street is not barred bv the statute of limitations. The city is J d invested by the legislature with governmental powers, and holds the fee of the street, or an easemen(; thereon, in trust for the public. Ogg v. City of Lansing, 35 Iowa, 495; Calwell v. City of Boone, 51 Id., 687; City of Clinton v. Cedar Rapids & M. R. R’y Co., 24 Id., 455. The city is but an instrument for the exercise of the authority of the state, and its municipal powers in establishing and maintaining a street are exercised in the discharge of governmental functions. The statute of limitations, therefore, will not run to defeat the exercise of its governmental authority. In cases wherein arise questions involving property or contracts which do not pertain to the exercise of their authority, the statute will run. Davis v. Huebner, 45 Iowa, 574; City of Burlington v. Burlington & M. R. R’y Co., 41 Id., 134; City of Pella v. Scholte, 24 Id., 283; Dill. Mun. Corp., § 675, and cases cited in notes; City of Alton v. Illinois Transportation Co., 12 Ill., 38; Supervisors of Logan Co. v. City of Lincoln, 81 Ill., 156; County of Piatt v. Goodell, 97 Ill., 84; City of Vicksburg v. Marshall, 59 Miss., 563; Brooks v. Riding, 46 Ind., 15; Sims v. City of Frankfort, 79 Ind., 446.
These considerations lead us to the conclusion that the case was rightly decided by the circuit court.
AFFIRMED.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.