Beard & Sons v. Illinois Central Railway Co.
Cases that cite this one
28 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Gehrke v. American Railway Express Co. (N.D. 1931)
- Hardesty v. American Railway Express Co. (Superior Court of Delaware 1922)
- Erisman v. Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad (Iowa 1917)
- Dunlap v. Great Northern Railway Co. (S.D. 1914)
- Brennisen v. Pennsylvania Railroad (Minn. 1907)
- Taffe v. Oregon Railroad (Or. 1902)
- Shea v. Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Co. (Minn. 1896)
- Myerson v. Woolverton (New York Court of Common Pleas 1894)
- House v. Wheelock (Ill. App. Ct. 1929)
- Dye Produce Co. v. Davis (Iowa 1925)
- Pennsylvania Railroad v. Walker (Md. 1925)
- E. H. Emery & Co. v. American Reprigerator Transit Co. (Iowa 1921)
- Bobzein v. New York Central Railroad (Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of New York 1919)
- E. H. Emery & Co. v. Chicago, Burlington & Quincy Railroad (Iowa 1919)
- McNamara v. Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Co. (Iowa 1918)
- Glassman v. Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway (Iowa 1914)
- I. N. Price & Co. v. Erie Railroad (Ohio Superior Court, Cincinnati 1912)
- Mittenthal v. Michigan Central Railroad (Ill. App. Ct. 1912)
- Rick v. Wells Fargo Co. (Utah 1911)
- Colsch v. Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co. (Iowa 1910)
- Stone v. Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Co. (Iowa 1910)
- St. Louis, Iron Mountain & Southern Railway Co. v. Renfroe (Ark. 1907)
- C. C. Taft Co. v. American Express Co. (Iowa 1907)
- State ex rel. Washington Mill Co. v. Great Northern Railway Co. (Wash. 1906)
- Martin v. Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway Co. (Iowa 1902)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
II. We will proceed to inquire as to the duty of defendant upon receiving the butter in a car from the Cairo. Short Line for transportation to New Orleans, without directions or instructions as to the character of the car in which it should be carried, i A carrier’s duty is not limited to the transportation of goods delivered for carriage.He must exercise such diligence as is required by law to protect the goods from destruction and injury resulting from conditions which, in the,-(exercise of due care, may be averted or counteracted. He must guard the goods from destruction or injury by the elements ; from the effects of delays ; indeed, from every source of injury which he may avert, and which, in the exercise of care and ordinary intelligence, may be known or anticipated. j Unknown causes, or those which are inherent in the nature of the goods, and cannot be, in the exercise of diligence, averted, will not render the carrier liable. The nature of the goods must be considered in determining the carrier’s duty. - Some metals may be transported in open cars. Many articles of commerce, when transported, must be protected from rain, sunshine and heat,
-In the case before us the marks on the packages and the way-bill disclosed that the subject of shipment was butter. The employes of defendant were endowed with intelligence which taught them that the season was summer, when warm weather prevailed; that butter, in common cars, would be greatly injured by the ordinary heat of the climate; and that the butter, as it approached its destination, would be subject, by reason of the change of latitude, to greatly increased heat from the weather. All these things are familiarly known to all men. Surely, the law will presume that defendant’s employes had full knowledge thereof. The law required the defendant, " having received the perishable cargo Í involved in this suit, to exercise the care and diligence necessary to protect it;'and, if improved cars for the® transportation of articles of commerce liable to injury from heat were in use, it was defendant’s duty to use such cars in carrying the butter. These views are supported by the following, among other, cases: Hewett v. Railway Co., 63 Iowa, 611; Sager v. Railway Co., 31 Me. 228; Hawkins v. Railway Co., 17 Mich. 62, 18 Mich. 427; Railway Co. v. Pratt, 22 Wall. 123; Wing v. Railway Co., 1 Hilt. 241; Merchants’ Dispatch & Trans. Co. v. Cornforth,. 3 Colo. 280. As to the duty of defendant to use cars so constructed and used as to avoid injury from heat, see Hutch. Carr., sec. 294; Boscowitz v. Express Co., 93 Ill. 525; Steinweg v. Railway Co., 43 N. Y. 123.
III. But it is said': (1) That defendant did not have refrigerator cars which it could have used on the day it received the butter; (2) that the cars were sealed; (3) that it was accustomed to haul the cars received
IY. It is said that the rate of charges, as shown by the way-bill, was for common cars, and the defendant, therefore, undertook to furnish no other kind. If the freight charges fixed in the way-bill do not express a contract that the butter may be transported so as to destroy its value, and that the carrier is excused from the exercise of the care required of him by law, we think the freight charges in no case will limit the care to be exercised by the carrier, and restrict his liability. /The defendant, was not restricted, by the rate of freight charges named in the way-bill, from claiming and enforcing the payment of a Just compensation for charges incurred on account of outlays made in order to safely transport the goods. Sumner v. Railway Association, 7 Baxt. 345. Many of the rulings of the district court upon the admission of evidence and instructions
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.