Smith v. Gorrell
Cases that cite this one
13 later published cases cite this decision.
- Sheridan County v. Spiro (Wyo. 1985)
- Incorporated Town of Cambridge v. Cook (Iowa 1896)
- Kreiger v. Kreiger (Ky. Ct. App. 1922)
- Merrill v. Hutchins (Iowa 1917)
- Ford v. Doolittle (Iowa 1912)
- McClenehan v. Town of Jesup (Iowa 1909)
- Quinn v. Baage (Iowa 1907)
- Weber v. City of Iowa City (Iowa 1903)
- Corey v. City of Fort Dodge (Iowa 1902)
- City of Davenport v. Boyd (Iowa 1899)
- Uptagraff v. Smith (Iowa 1898)
- Johnson v. City of Burlington (Iowa 1895)
- Crismon v. Deck (Iowa 1892)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This action was commenced April 28, 1888. The plaintiff is the owner of the southeast quarter of the southeast quarter of section twenty-four, township eighty, range twenty, in Jasper county. The defendant Groebel is supervisor of the road district in which the land is situated, and threatens to enter upon
The district court found in favor of Gorrell, and, as to him, dismissed the petition. It further found that plaintiff was the absolute and unqualified owner of the land described excepting a strip thirty feet wide on the south side thereof. It further found that the highway in question was established in December, 1858, along the south side of said forty-acre tract, and that it included the strip described. The court also found that notice of the establishment of said road and of the right to claim damages by reason thereof had never been given to the owner of the land, excepting as it was imported by the passage of the acts specified, and the filing of the commissioner’s report with the county judge, and that the question of damages had never been determined. It was also found that the strip had been inclosed with the remainder of the forty-acre tract for more than fifteen years continuously prior to the commencement of this action, under a claim adverse to the public; that the agent of the owner who first inclosed the tract had actual knowledge of the location of the road in question; that no work had been done by the public on the strip described, and no travel had passed over it for more than fifteen years prior to the commencement of this suit; that Groebel, as road supervisor, was about to enter upon the strip for the purpose
The motion to dismiss is in part based upon the alleged ground that the evidence offered, and the evidence introduced, on the trial in the district court was not‘so preserved and certified that the cause can be tried here de novo. It is not necessary to specify the questions presented by the motion, since all of them fall within the decisions of this court heretofore announced in the form of opinions. It is sufficient to say that it is made to appear by numerous papers filed that the evidence in question was duly preserved, and made a part of the record in the manner and within the time required by law. The motion to dismiss and to strike is overruled.
We conclude that plaintiff is entitled to the relief demanded. It follows that the county of Jasper is not liable for damages. The judgment of the district court, as to the appeal of both plaintiff and the county of Jasper, is reversed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.