Capital City State Bank v. Des Moines Cotton-Mill Co.
Opinion of the Court
The note in suit is for twenty-three hundred *and seven dollars and eighty-four cents running to the plaintiff hank, and is dated “4th mo.— 7 — 1889/’ and signed by all of the defendants. The defendants, J. F. and E. R. Mason, alone answer that they are accommodation makers of the note for the plaintiff bank. The particular facts upon which the defendants rely for their defense are, in brief, that the note in suit is a renewal of a note for the same amount, signed by the defendants, the Des Moines Cotton-Mill Company, and the York Investment Company to the plaintiff bank, and by it indorsed and discounted at the Iowa National Bank. The party primarily liable for the payment of the first note was the cotton-mill company, of which E. R. Mason was president and J. F. Mason secretary and manager. The same primary liability is also to the note in suit. At the maturity of the first note, the Iowa National Bank presented it for payment to the plaintiff bank, which gave its certificate of deposit to the Iowa National Bank for the amount of the note. It also appears from the answer that the renewed note now in suit was signed by the defendants, and deposited with the Iowa National Bank in lieu of the note for which it is a renewal; that they signed the note only as accommodation makers for the plaintiff bank without a previous liability on their part; and that the plaintiff bank has paid the note.
At the close of the defendants’ evidence, the court, on motion of the plaintiff, directed a verdict in its favor on the ground that there was no evidence showing that the defendants were accommodation makers of the note, and this ruling presents the only question in the case. The direction of the court was a
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.