Sioux Valley State Bank v. Honnold
Cases that cite this one
14 later published cases cite this decision.
- Brownlee v. Masterson (Iowa 1933)
- Evans v. Stewart (Iowa 1954)
- Mason City and Clear Lake R. Co. v. Imperial Seed Co. (District Court, N.D. Iowa 1957)
- Ginsberg v. Lindel (8th Cir. 1939)
- Beh v. Tilk (Iowa 1936)
- Lamoine Mott Estate v. Neiman (8th Cir. 1935)
- Girard v. Anderson (Iowa 1934)
- Brenton v. Bream (Iowa 1926)
- Lewin v. Telluride Iron Works Co. (8th Cir. 1921)
- Commercial Credit Corp. v. Interstate Finance Corp. (Iowa 1945)
- Reese v. Lamp (Iowa 1923)
- Hays v. Berry (Iowa 1898)
- Hipsley v. Price (Iowa 1897)
- Smith v. Dayton (Iowa 1895)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
In January, 1889, certain land was leased to the defendants J. O. and H. C. Honnold. As a part of the rental for the leased premises, they made a promissory note for the sum of five hundred dollars, payable on the first day of March, 1890. The plaintiff is the owner of that note, and commenced this action soon after it became due. A writ of attachment
4‘And it is further underátood and agreed by and between these parties that any breach of this contract, and any damage that the first party may sustain by reason of the second party failing to perform this contract, such as failing to do plowing, failing to harvest, stack and thresh grain at proper time, and to deliver-first party’s share according to this contract, and any other failure and damage resulting from such breach,, shall be the same as rent due, and the first party shall have a lien for such damage on all crops growing or grown on said land, and on any and all property of the-second party taken upon or used on said premises during the continuance of this lease, whether the same be exempt from execution or not, under the statutes of' Iowa.”
The plaintiff claims a lien upon the property in controversy by virtue of this provision. The inter-venors claim a prior lien thereon by virtue of two chattel mortgages which were executed by H. C. Honnold,— one of which was given in September, 1889, and the other in November of the same year. The lease was not recorded, and the intervenors had no knowledge of its provisions when the mortgages were taken. The-question we are required to determine is whether an agreement between the landlord and tenant, which is. designed to extend the landlord’s lien to personal property which is exempt from execution, is effectual as against a subsequent mortgagee without notice. The-landlord’s lien is purely statutory, and is conferred by
The statute gives the landlord no lien upon property which is exempt from execution. Abraham v. Davenport, 73 Iowa, 111. A provision in the lease which creates a lien on such property is in'its nature and effect a mortgage, and will be governed by the law applicable to instruments of that character, so far as applicable. The provision under consideration cannot be regarded as a mere waiver of the right to claim the exemption. It does not purport to be a waiver, and, if it were so intended, would be invalid. In Curtis v. O’Brien, 20 Iowa, 376, it was held that a waiver of the exemption laws contained in. a promissory note was ineffectual because against public policy, although the maker of the note might have given a valid mortgage on his exempt property, to secure the .payment of the •debt. The same doctrine was announced in Kneetle v. Newcomb, 22 N. Y. 249. But the well-settled rules of ■construction require that where a contract is susceptible of two interpretations, by one of which it would be held valid, and by the other void, that one must be adopted which would make it valid. Therefore, if the intent of the parties were doubtful, we would be required to hold that the provision in question was not a mere waiver, but was intended to be in the nature of a mortgage. The language used, however, clearly indicates that such was the effect intended by the parties. In Fejavary v. Broesch, 52 Iowa, 88, a provision similar to that under consideration was held not to be a waiver of the exemption, and not technically a mortgage, but it was said that it created a lien or equitable charge, the validity of which, well as the right of a party to execute it, as
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.