Bucy v. Pitts Agricultural Works
Cases that cite this one
20 later published cases cite this decision.
- Fetzer v. Haralson (Tex. App. 1912)
- Petersen v. Dreher (Iowa 1923)
- Rasmus v. AO Smith Corporation (District Court, N.D. Iowa 1958)
- Investors' Mortgage Security Co. v. Strauss & Co. (Idaho 1931)
- Davenport Ladder Co. v. Edward Hines Lumber Co. (8th Cir. 1930)
- Hercules Powder Co. v. Rich (8th Cir. 1924)
- E. F. Elmberg Co. v. Dunlap Hardware Co. (Tex. Comm'n App. 1924)
- J. L. Owens Co. v. Leland Farmers Elevator Co. (Iowa 1921)
- Glencoe Ditching Co. v. Martin (Minn. 1921)
- Bullock Tractor Co. v. Knapp (9th Cir. 1921)
- Michigan Pipe Co. v. Sullivan County Water Co. (Ind. 1920)
- Penn American Plate Glass Co. v. De La Vergne Machine Co. (Ind. Ct. App. 1914)
- Loxtercamp v. Lininger Implement Co. (Iowa 1910)
- Wasatch Orchard Co. v. Morgan Canning Co. (Utah 1907)
- J. I. Case Threshing Machine Co. v. E. B. Hall & Keating Implement Co. (Tex. App. 1903)
- Fruit Dispatch Co. v. C. C. Taft Co. (Iowa 1924)
- John A. Roebling's Sons Co. v. Southern Power Co. (Ga. 1914)
- Tracy Land Co. v. Polk County Land & Loan Co. (Iowa 1906)
- Ideal Heating Co. v. Kramer (Iowa 1905)
- Timken Carriage Co. v. C. S. Smith & Co. (Iowa 1904)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
On the trial the appellant introduced in evidence, without objection, an order to the appellant upon a printed blank, filled up in writing, for a threshing machine, and purporting to be signed by the appellees. There was evidence tending to show that the appellees had signed the order. They testified that they did not remember of doing so. Said order contains the following: “The Pitts Agricultural Works warrant said machine to be of good materials, and to be well made; to do good work in threshing and cleaning grain, if properly managed. The condition of warranty is that notice of any defect is to be given the Pitts Agricultural Works at Buffalo, New York, within one week after putting the machine in operation.”
The. case was submitted as upon the implied warranty, and the jury instructed that “the only question for you to consider is whether the threshing machine did or did not comply with this implied undertaking,
The effect of this instruction was to withdraw the written warranty from the consideration of the jury, and of this the appellant complains, contending that it was proper evidence, under section 2704 of the Code, which is as follows: “Under a denial of an allegation, no evidence shall be introduced which does not tend to negative some fact the party making the controverted allegation is bound to prove.” To apply this rule, we must ascertain what controverted allegations, that the appellee was bound to prove, this evidence tended to negative.
There are authorities holding that, where there is an express warranty, none will be implied, upon the theory that by the express warranty the parties have stated, in words, that by which they agreed to be bound. It is held, in this and many other states, that this rule does not extend to the exclusion of warranties implied by law where they are not excluded by the terms of the contract. “A warranty will not be implied in conflict with the express terms of the contract.” Blackmore v. Fairbanks, Morse & Co., 79 Iowa, 282. The rule dedueible from the authorities is that an implied and an express warranty may exist under the same contract, as when the expressed does not relate to the obli
The appellees alleged, and because of the appellant’s denial were bound to prove, an implied warranty, an obligation that was not lessened by the fact that they might prove it by showing a contract from which the law would imply a warranty that the machine was reasonably suited for its intended purpose. If the appellant had offered a written contract wherein the appellees had agreed to take the machine as it was without any warranty, its admissibility would hardly be questioned, because it would tend to negative the controverted allegations that there was an implied warranty, and - that there was no written warranty. The printed warranty introduced by the defendant had the same tendency. It relates to the same subject and obligations that an implied warranty would, and, under the law, became the contract, to the exclusion of all implications as to that subject or those obligations. It directly negatived the existence of the implied warranty, and equally so the alleged oral warranty, as the writing must be taken as expressing in full the agreement of the parties. It can not be said that the exclusion of this evidence was without prejudice to the appellant. The appellees had no right to recover upon any other than the contract of
,Our conclusion is that the judgment of the district court must be reversed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.