Templin v. Incorporated City of Boone
Cases that cite this one
25 later published cases cite this decision.
- Alber v. City of Dubuque (Iowa 1960)
- Baker v. Decker (Utah 1949)
- Beach v. City of Des Moines (Iowa 1947)
- Taylor v. City of Sibley (Iowa 1947)
- Moore v. Miles (Utah 1945)
- Geagley v. City of Bedford (Iowa 1944)
- Tillotson v. City of Davenport (Iowa 1942)
- Hoffman v. City of Sioux City (Iowa 1940)
- City of Rome v. Potts (Ga. Ct. App. 1932)
- Gregg v. Town of Springville (Iowa 1919)
- Covert v. Town of Lovilia (Iowa 1914)
- Jackson v. City of Grand Forks (N.D. 1913)
- Thompson v. City of Sigourney (Iowa 1931)
- Tollackson v. City of Eagle Grove (Iowa 1927)
- Smith v. City of Sioux City (Iowa 1925)
- Parks v. City of Des Moines (Iowa 1923)
- Travers v. City of Emmetsburg (Iowa 1921)
- Fletcher v. Ketcham (Iowa 1920)
- Daniels v. Iowa City (Iowa 1920)
- Pedelty Thresher Co. v. Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co. (Iowa 1920)
- Dempsey v. City of Dubuque (Iowa 1911)
- Reynolds v. City of Centerville (Iowa 1911)
- Fuller v. Incorporated Town (Iowa 1911)
- Scurlock v. City of Boone (Iowa 1909)
- Crandall v. City of Dubuque (Iowa 1907)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Plaintiff, wbo lost a limb during tbe Civil War, and wbo bas since tbat worn an artificial one, slipped and fell upon a sidewalk in one of tbe streets of-defendant city, and received tbe injuries of wbicb be complains. He charges tbat about ten days prior to tbe time of tbe accident, wbicb was on tbe morning of January 4, 1903, tbe city permitted an accumulation of snow and ice upon tbe sidewalk, wbicb it negligently allowed to become and remain in a rough, rounded, irregular, and unsafe condition, dangerous to persons using said walk, and hazardous to all passersby. Defendant denied all negligence, and claimed, in effect, that tbe defect, if there was one, was due to a fall of rain and sleet on tbe evening preceding the accident, over wbicb it had no control; and further insisted tbat plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence in bis attempt to pass over tbe walk. In answers to special interrogatories, tbe jury found tbat there bad been an accumulation óf ice and snow 'at tbe place of accident for an unreasonable length of time; that defendant bad notice of the dangerous condition of tbe sidewalk prior to tbe time plaintiff received bis injuries; and that be (plaintiff) was not guilty of contributory negligence.
For a reversal of tbe judgment defendant relies upon, three propositions: (1) That there is no evidence of its negligence; (2) tbat plaintiff did not show freedom from
The rules of law in such cases are well understood. The mere fact that a sidewalk is dangerous because of the presence of ice and snow is not sufficient to establish negligence on the part of a city, even though this snow and ice are not removed within a reasonable time. But where, by reason of travel or the action of the elements, it becomes rounded or worn into ridges, uneven and irregular, due care on the part of the city may demand its removal. Huston v. City, 101 Iowa, 33, and cases cited. And if the city be negligent in allowing ice and snow upon its sidewalks to become and remain in a dangerous and unsafe condition, it cannot avoid liability for injuries received thereon, by showing that the iciness or slippery condition of the walk was caused by natural causes, as by rain or sleet, or sudden changes of the weather. If the accident would not have happened but for the previous rough, uneven, /and rounded condition of the walk, due to the presence of ice and snow thereon, then the city may be liable, although there is another irresponsible condition concurring with defendant’s fault in producing the injury. Salzer v. City, 97 Wis., 471 (73 N. W. Rep. 20); Langhammer v. City, 99 Iowa, 295; Collins v. City, 32 Iowa, 324; Shumway v. City, 108 Iowa, 424; Ford v. City, 106 Iowa, 94.
Now, the evidence shows that the walk in question was
In another instruction, in referring to constructive notice, the court said, “ It is based upon a finding by the jury.”
IV. The case is not strong in its facts, but there were enough to take it to the jury. The instructions were not prejudicially erroneous, and no enror appears which would justify us in reversing the case. The verdict was small, considering the nature of plaintiff’s injuries, and we shall not interfere therewith. — ■ Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.