Citizens State Bank v. Chambers
Citizens State Bank v. Chambers
Opinion of the Court
Exhibit A. Application for Loan.
I, the undersigned, do hereby appoint S. S. Dillenbeck & Son, of Citizens’ State Bank, Perry, Iowa, as my agents to procure for me a loan of $5,000.00 for the term of ten years, from February 1, 1902, at five and one per cent, per annum from 1-22-1902, to be paid semiannually, secured by first mortgage upon the following described real estate, situated in the county of Greene and State of Iowa, to-wit: The northwest quarter of section number thirty-five (35) and the north half of the southwest quarter of Sec. 35, Twp. 82, range 29, except eight acres off of side of said eighty-acre tract. For the purpose of procuring said loan, I declare the following statement to be true: Total No. of acres, two hundred and thirty-two. Acres cultivated, one hundred and thirty-two. The said property is not rented, but is occupied by myself. Are there any mortgages, judgments, taxes, or other liens against the property ? Yes. If so, describe them, giving amount, name of mortgagee, and when due. Loan of $1,600 at five per cent., two years’ interest due, to G. L. Peck, opt. 5-3 — 1902. $2,000.00 to C. W. Williams, opt. 2 — 1—1902, to Elisha Nichols. The money is borrowed for the purpose of paying above mortgages and purchase price. I own other property of the value of $4,000. My total liabilities at this time do not exceed the sum of $1,650. If this application is accepted, I will furnish, at my own expense, a complete abstract of title to the land proposed as security, ipd pay for stamping and recording the mortgage. I also agree to furnish the mortgagee each year, during the continuance of said loan, with evidence that all taxes against said property have been paid. T am a- married woman and am seventy-four years old. My husband’s name in full*416 is Alexander Chambers. He is - years old. My post-office address is Angus, Iowa. I have appointed S. S. Dillenbeck & Son my agent to assist me in obtaining said loan, to whom the money and papers may be sent, at my risk. Options in even hundreds, at five per cent, interest period. And I further agree to pay ten dollars for examining the permises herein referred to and the title thereto if the security should not be as represented.
Elizabeth (X) Chambers.
Mack Stevens.
The firm of Dillenbeck & Son is composed of S. S. Dillenbeck and B. C. Dillenbeck, who are, respectively, president and cashier of the plaintiff bank, and carry on their loan business in the bank. Thereafter Mrs. Chambers and her husband made and executed to Dillenbeck & Son the following written instruments:
(1) A promissory note of $5,000, payable to the order of S. S. Dillenbeck &,S<m, due 10 years after date, with interest at 5 per cent., payable semiannually. The note also contained a clause by which the makers had the privilege of making payments on the principal at any interest period.
(2) A mortgage to S. S'. Dillenbeck & Son to secure the payment of said promissory note of $15,000.
(3) A promissory note of $500, payable to S. S. Dillenbeck & Son in installments, and is in the following words:
$500.00 Perry, Iowa, January 23, 1902.
For value received, we, Elizabeth 'Chambers and Alexander Chambers, wife and husband, promise to pay to S. S. Dillenbeck & Son, or order, five hundred dollars, payable in twenty equal installments of twenty-five dollars each. The first installment of twenty-five ($25) will become due and payable on the first day of August, 1902, and the second installment of twenty-five ($25) will become clue and payable on the first day of February, 1903, and the balance to he paid in eighteen (18) equal installments of twenty-five ($25) each, on the first day of each succeeding month of August and February, thereafter, until the aforesaid sum of*417 five hundred dollars is paid in full, with interest at the rate of eight per cent, per annum payable semiannually from maturity until paid. Unpaid interest shall bear interest at the rate of eight per cent, per annum from the time the same becomes due. And it is further agreed that if default is made in the payment of principal or interest, then the whole shall become due and payable at once. In case suit is commenced for the collection of this note, the makers hereof agree to pay all reasonable costs, including attorney’s fees.
Elizabeth (X) Chambers.
Alexander (X) Chambers.
Witness to marks: Mack Stevens.
(4) A mortgage to S. S. Dillenbeck & Son to secure the payment of said note for $500; said security being made subject to the lien of the mortgage first-above mentioned.
These notes and mortgages immediately, or at least very soon after the application, were signed and the amount of the loan was at once fúrnished by Dillenbeck & Son on their own account and paid out for the benefit of the borrowers in satisfying and removing certain prior liens and charges upon the land. The Dillenbecks, according to their testimony, held the principal note and mortgage some three or four months, when they sold and assigned it to a party in Connecticut, retaining the note for $500 secured by second mortgage. The negotiations for the sale of said mortgage were not concluded until within about three weeks, of the first interest day, August 1, 1902, when the purchaser paid Dillenbeck & Son the amount of the principal note, with interest accrued to that date at 5 per cent. Within a month or two after obtaining the loan from the Dillenbecks the Chambers sold the land to the defendant James Wimmer, who assumed payment of the debt. On the arrival of the first interest day Wimmer claimed the right to exercise the option reserved in the principal note to pay the entire debt. lie paid, and the bank on part of the owner accepted, the full amount of $5,000, with five per cent, interest thereon, and the note and mortgage were surrendered and canceled.
To ascertain the contract between the parties, we must look first to the writing. Recurring to its language it unquestionably appears that IVIrs. Chambers and her husband authorized Dillenbeek & Son to procure for them a loan upon certain specified terms, to wit, “ a loan of $5,000 for the term of ten years from February 1, 1902, at five and one per cent, per annum from 1 — 22—1902, to be paid semiannually secured by first mortgage upon [describing the land]. . . . Options in even hundreds at five per cent, interest period.”
If we look to the writing alone, and such is the elementary general rule in the absence of allegations or proof of fraud, we think it impossible to discover, in the language
But we think there is no occasion in this case to resort to proof of custom or usage to determine with certainty the real nature and effect of the transaction between the appellants and Billenbeck & Son. Conceding, for the purposes of the case, that the testimony was all properly admitted and giving it its utmost probative effect, we are still of the opinion that in view of the undisputed facts the appellee is not entitled to recover.
Looking at the practical construction placed by the parties upon the contract, we find that, instead of negotiating a loan from some third party for the borrowers, the Billenbecks themselves made the loan from their own funds at “ five and one per cent.,” taking their chances of marketing the< paper on a basis which would leave them a margin of profit. This fact shows quite conclusively that the “ five and one per cent.” was understood by the parties as only another way of saying “ six per cent, interest,” (the division into “ five and one ” being made to facilitate the marketing of the security by the lenders), for there could be no such thing as commission to the lenders for making a loan of their own money. This feature of the case will be emphasized by considering what would have been the rights of the
It follows from what we have said tbe decree appealed from must be, and is, reversed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Citizens State Bank of Perry v. Elizabeth Chambers, Alexander Chambers, James Wimmer
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published