Page County v. Rose
Cases that cite this one
32 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Lucas County v. Jamison (U.S. Circuit Court for the Southern District of Iowa 1908)
- Leach v. Battle Creek Savings Bank (Iowa 1926)
- Central Bank v. Lowdermilk (Ariz. 1922)
- In re Receivership of Mediapolis St. Bk. (Iowa 1935)
- Reichert v. Plymouth United Savings Bank (Mich. 1934)
- Pittsburgh's Appeal (Pa. 1934)
- County of Traverse v. Veigel (Minn. 1929)
- Eastman v. Farmers State Bank of Olivia (Minn. 1928)
- Adams v. Farmers State Bank of Olivia (Minn. 1928)
- Sinclair Refining Co. v. Tierney (N.M. 1928)
- Grand Forks County v. Baird (N.D. 1926)
- Bignell v. Cummins (Mont. 1923)
- Empire State Surety Co. v. Carroll County (8th Cir. 1912)
- State v. Bruce (Idaho 1909)
- Andrew v. Iowa Savings Bank (Iowa 1932)
- In re Guardianship of Aasheim (Iowa 1931)
- Ward v. Fulton (Ohio Ct. App. 1931)
- Leach v. Stockport Savings Bank (Iowa 1929)
- Andrew v. Darrow Trust & Savings Bank (Iowa 1928)
- Special Road District No. 4 v. Cantley (Mo. Ct. App. 1928)
- First National Bank v. United States Fidelity & Guaranty Co. (Or. 1928)
- Rundel v. Boone County (Iowa 1927)
- Leach v. Farmers Savings Bank (Iowa 1927)
- Leach v. Mechanics Savings Bank (Iowa 1926)
- City of New Hampton v. Leach (Iowa 1926)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
For several years Luther Van Arsdol, under the business name and style of the Bank of Coin, conducted a private banking business at the town of Coin, in Page county, Iowa. On the 9th day of March, 1904, Van Arsdol, having become insolvent, made a general assignment under the insolvency statute of the state to Ed. F. Eose and Charles Hart for the benefit of his' creditors. Prior to the insolvency and assignment of Van Arsdol, and beginning January 6, 1902, an arrangement existed between the bank and the treasurer of Page county, one W. L. Lundy, whereby the tax receipts of persons living in the vicinity of Coin were sent to the bank, with authority to the bank to receive the money thereon and deliver the receipts to the parties paying the same. The account thus created in favor of the treasurer was checked or drawn upon by him from time to time. The account was kept in the name of “ W. L. Lundy, Treasurer,” and it was known by the bank at all times that this account represented a balance due said treasurer or the county for taxes collected as aforesaid. During the period referred to the bank collected and received from taxpayers for treasurer’s receipts surrendered • by it an aggregate sum of $5,919.95, and at the time of the assignment of Van Arsdol the balance due to the treasurer on this account was $1,199.47, for which sum the county filed a claim against the insolvent’s estate, asking that the same be established as a preferred claim and paid in full before any distribution to the general creditors. It is agreed by the parties that payments of the taxes to the bank was effected, in part by payments in cash, and in part by the cheeks of the taxpayers upon deposits held for them by the bank, and in other cases the bank charged the amount of the tax receipts against the deposit accounts of their
It is matter of common knowledge that in most of our counties a very large fraction of the taxes is collected by and through banks doing business in towns other than the county seat, and that the custom is one of much convenience and advantage to a large number of the taxpayers. But while this is true, it remains equally true that the treasurer' in doing so exceeds the strict letter of his authority, and the loss by the failure of a bank holding moneys thus received is primarily his loss. It is, however, within the right of the county, which traces its moneys thus collected into the hands of the bank, to demand and recover it. In the legal sense of the word the deposit of the money in the bank, or its retention by the bank, is wrongful, and- it holds such money charged with a trust in favor of the real party in interest. On this and other propositions involved in this appeal, see Taylor County v. Standley, 79 Iowa, 670; Smith v. Bank, 107 Iowa, 624; Plow Co. v. Lamp, 80 Iowa, 723; Cook v. Tullis, 85 U. S. 341 (21 L. Ed. 933) ; McClure v. La Plata Co., 19 Colo. 122 (34 Pac. 763); State v. Bevers, 86 N. C. 594; Kirby v. Wilson, 98 Ill. 240; Frigh v. Cartland, 2 Hen. & M. 417; Englar v. Offutt, 70 Md. 78 (16 Atl. 497, 14 Am. St. Rep. 332) ; Harrison v. Smith, 83 Mo. 210 (53 Am. Rep. 571) ; Bank v. Ins. Co., 104 U. S. 54 (26 L. Ed. 693) ; Brewing Association v. Morris, 36 Neb. 33 (53 N. W. 1037) ; Capital Bank v. Coldwater Bank, 49 Neb. 789 (69 N. W. 115, 59 Am. St.
We find no error in the record, and the judgment of the trial court is affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.