Poitevin v. Binnall
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Spooner v. Spooner (Iowa 1943)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
Plaintiff and defendant are sister and brother. The premises in controversy were duly conveyed to the plaintiff by warranty deed executed by her father. The defendant set up an alleged previous contract between him and his father purporting to have been executed April 24, 1882, whereby the father agreed to convey the land in question “in and for the consideration of -labor,” and “if the party of the second part shall remain at home and upon said property so long as the party of the first part shall live.” This claim on the part of -the defendant was first set up on March 29, 1905, in a substituted answer and cross-petition filed on such date, his original answer having been filed in November preceding. On the same day an order of reference was made by consent of parties to -one Wheeler as referee. At that time no reply had been filed to the substituted answer and cross-petition. The case came on for hearing before the referee on April 25 th. On that day the plaintiff filed a reply to the substituted answer and cross-petition, and observed the formality of having it properly marked and entered as filed by .the clerk of the court and by the referee. The defendant moved to strike it, and objected to its consideration by the referee, and insisted that the case be heard upon the issues as made by the pleadings prior to such filing. -He contended that such pleading was not an “amendment,” and that therefore the referee had no power to permit the same to be filed, nor any right to regard the same as filed. Defendant’s objections in this regard were all- overruled, and the referee proceeded with the hearing of evidence. After the evidence was heard, the plaintiff undertook to fortify her position by obtaining an order of the judge in vacation, which order was first issued and afterwards revoked, and which we do not deem material for our present consideration. At the September term, while the reference was still pending, the
Section 3739 provides that the trial by the referee shall be conducted in “the same manner as the trial by the court.” This section also provides that the referee shall have the “same power . . . to allow amendments to pleadings.” Section 3748 provides that the “form of procedure which in the court itself regulates service, pleading,
It is argued that this new pleading presented new issues which had not been submitted to the referee by the order of reference, and that he was therefore without power to try them. This objection of defendant could as well be directed against an amendment to a pleading which may and usually does present new issues. New issues pending trial are not forbidden by the statute, although orderly procedure requires that, as far as possible, issues be made before reference is had. The discretion of the trial court, however, is always broad enough to deal with the particular facts of each case. And we are not now dealing with the question whether the discretion was properly exercised. We are united in the opinion that the referee had power under the statute to permit the filing of plaintiff’s reply on April 25th. In Johnson v. Berdo, 131 Iowa, 524, it was held that in order to file a pleading before the referee it was necessary that the formal statutory entries should be made by the clerk. This formality was complied with here.
This question being disposed of, it leaves little for our consideration but questions of fact. The case was orally argued before the full bench, and we have gone through the printed record with care, and are united in the conclusion that .the clear weight of the evidence is with -the plaintiff on every essential fact in dispute. Inasmuch
The decree of the trial court was right and it is affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.