Great Western Accident Insurance v. Martin
Cases that cite this one
8 later published cases cite this decision.
- Smith v. Newell (Iowa 1962)
- Kruse v. Gaines (Iowa 1966)
- State Ex Rel. Weede v. Iowa Southern Utilities Co. of Delaware (Iowa 1942)
- Tavener v. Tax Commission (Iowa 1941)
- Workman v. District Court (Iowa 1936)
- Farmers Insurance v. Linn County (Iowa 1926)
- City of New Albany v. Lemon (Ind. 1925)
- Iowa Life Insurance v. Board of Supervisors (Iowa 1921)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
This conclusion is reinforced ■ by the fact that Section 1310 fixes its own exceptions as to shares; wherefore, the legislature did not intend that other statutes should be looked to for exceptions. . Moreover, Section 1310 not only makes its own exceptions, as, for instance, shares of loan and trust companies, but requires that those who desire a definition of the excepted classes shall ascertain, by investigating, how such classes are “hereinafter” defined. Certainly, Section 1310 did not intend that Section 1305 should be looked to. For that statute is not “hereinafter.” Certainly, “hereinafter” does not refer to a preceding section.
There is nothing in Layman v. Iowa Tel. Co., 123 Iowa 591, nor in Morril v. Bentley, 150 Iowa 677, which has any
II. It may be true that the statute exhibits unfairness. If there were any substantial doubt concerning the legislative intent, fairness and unfairness would enter into determining what construction the státute should have. But if it were ever so clear that Section 1310 works unfairness, it is just as clear that the legislature intended that unfairness, and that no íegitimaté construction can reach any other result than that these shares shall be assessed at five mills, and no more. This being clear, it becomes immaterial, on 'the case presented, by appellant's, whether fairness demanded of the legislature that it should not thus fix the taxation of such shares. We cannot substitute for a plain legislative enactment what we would deem a fairer law.
We say so much as this in connection with a reference to what is presented on this appeal, because in the Layman case, supra,, there is found a decision declaring a taxation statute 'unconstitutional, and, for aught we know, it may have been cited as reinforcing the claim of unfairness. In other words, it may have been in the mind of counsel that the statute is unfairly discriminating to such an.extent as to render it unconstitutional. But no such claim is made in assignment, brief point, or argument, unless it be found in the fact that the Layman case is cited.
Reduced to its lowest terms, the record shows that an
In our opinion, the decree below should be,.and it is, therefore, — Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.