In re Estate of Petersen
Opinion of the Court
This is an appeal from the action of the court in construing a will. It appears that, on and prior to the 10th day of August, 1916, Myrtle Wart Petersen was the owner of certain real estate and personal property, and on that date made a will. The parts material to this controversy only we set out:
“Second. I hereby devise and bequeath to my husband, P. N. Petersen, the statutoiw share of my property of which I die seized, it being my desire that he shall receive the same portion of my estate that he would if I did not make a will.
“That I hereby name and appoint my mother as executor of this will and my estate to act without bond and I hei'eby direct that as trustee of the property for my boy my mother shall hold title as trustee for him, act without bond and with authority to act regarding the property without order of the court.”
On her death, the will was duly probated and Anna Wart, mother of the testatrix, appointed executrix.
At the time of her death, testatrix left surviving her a husband, Peter P'etersen, Jr., her mother, Anna Wart, and a son, known in the record as John Peter Petersen. After the probate of the will, Peter Petersen, Jr., the father of John Peter Petersen-, was duly appointed guardian of the son, and at the time of the commencement of this proceeding, was acting as such.
On the 24th day of April, 1918, John Petersen, Jr., father and guardian of John P'eter Petersen, filed an application in the district court, alleging that doubts had arisen as to the true interpretation to be given to Paragraph 3 of the will, and claiming that, under a true interpretation, the trustee holds the property in trust for the minor, and that the minor, during his minority, is entitled to receive from said trustee income, rents, profits, and benefits derived and received by said trustee from said property.
The contention of the trustee is that she holds said
The question, therefore, is whether or not this will gives to the minor, John Peter Petersen, the income, rents, and profits derived from the property in the hands of the trustee, during his minority.
It is apparent that the legal title to the property devised vested in the trustee, Anna Wart; that the vesting of that title in the boy is contingent upon his reaching the age of 21. It is apparent that, during his minority, the title does not and cannot vest in him, under the terms of the will. His becoming of age was a condition precedent to the vesting of any title in him. His death before that time .prevents the vesting of title in him. The will clearly indicates that it was the intention of the testator that the title should not vest in the minor during his minority, and as clearly that it should never vest in him if death came before he reached his majority. There is nothing to indicate that the testator intended to separate the rents, profits, and income of the property from the property itself. There is no direct gift of the rents, profits, and income to this minor. All his rights in the property are dependent upon his living to the age of 21 years.
It is contended, however, that, inasmuch as the devise or bequest was made to the trustee, Anna Wart, in trust for the use and benefit of John Peter Petersen, until he was 21 years of age, this indicates a purpose on the part of testatrix that he should enjoy the income, rents, and profits of the property during his minority, and that, therefore, under this interpretation of the will, it was the duty of the trustee to pay to him, or his legally appointed guardian, the rents and profits as they accumulated during his minority. It will
We have-not been cited to any authorities directly bearing upon the question here under consideration, nor have we found any directly helpful in the solution of the question submitted. However, as bearing on the question, see In re Fritts’ Estate, 19 Misc. (N. Y.) 402 (44 N. Y. Supp. 344); Smith v. Parsons, 146 N. Y. 116 (40 N. E. 736).
The trial court found the guardian not entitled to the
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.