McGuire v. Grangeville Savings & Trust Co.
Idaho Supreme Court
McGuire v. Grangeville Savings & Trust Co., 19 Idaho 635 (Idaho 1911)
115 P. 18; 1911 Ida. LEXIS 46
Ailshie, Sullivan, Took, Woods
McGuire v. Grangeville Savings & Trust Co.
Opinion of the Court
(After stating the facts.) — This appeal was prosecuted from an order of the Honorable Edgar C. Steele, judge of the second judicial district, granting respondent a new trial upon the ground that the evidence in said action is insufficient to justify the verdict of the jury.
We have examined the evidence in this case as contained in the record, and it appearing therefrom that there was no abuse of discretion upon the part of the trial court in granting the motion for a new trial, the order made in the premises should be affirmed. It is therefore directed that the order granting a new trial be and the same is hereby affirmed. Costs awarded to respondent.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- P. A. McGUIRE v. GRANGEVILLE SAVINGS & TRUST CO.
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- Order Granting New Trial — Sufficiency of Evidence. (Syllabus by the court.) 1. Evidence in this case examined and considered and held that there was no abuse of the discretion vested in the trial court in granting a new trial.