Independent School District No. 1 v. Continental Oil Co.

Idaho Supreme Court
Independent School District No. 1 v. Continental Oil Co., 286 P. 360 (Idaho 1930)
49 Idaho 109; 1930 Ida. LEXIS 76
Varian, Givens, Budge, Lee, McNaughton

Independent School District No. 1 v. Continental Oil Co.

Opinion of the Court

VARIAN, J.-

In this case, the trial judge held Ordinance No. 322 of the city of Twin Falls invalid in so far as it applies to Block B, original town site of Twin Falls, Idaho, owned by respondent. The fundamental question involved *110 here is the validity of said ordinance. That question was decided adversely to. appellant’s contention in the case of Continental Oil Co. v. City of Twin Falls (No. 5268), ante, p. 89, 286 Pac. 353, wherein said ordinance is held to be unreasonable in its application to said Block B, and void as being discriminatory. It is therefore thought not necessary to consider the motion to dismiss the appeal, or the several assignments of error.

Judgment affirmed. Costs to respondent.

Givens, C. J., and Budge and Lee, JJ., concur. McNaughton, J., did not sit at the hearing and took no part in the decision.

Reference

Full Case Name
INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT No. 1 OF TWIN FALLS COUNTY, STATE OF IDAHO, a Municipal Corporation, Appellant, v. CONTINENTAL OIL COMPANY, a Corporation, Respondent
Cited By
9 cases
Status
Published