Appellate Court of Illinois, 1886

Holmes v. Holmes

Holmes v. Holmes
Appellate Court of Illinois · Decided November 20, 1886
21 Ill. App. 311; 1886 Ill. App. LEXIS 644

Counsel

Mr. I. A. Buckingham, for appellant., Messrs. Outten & Vail, for appellee.

Holmes v. Holmes

Opinion of the Court

Per Curiam.

.. The parties are brother and sister. She brought this suit for money alleged to be due her on a promissory note, and also for wages, and recovered a judgment for $1,039.85. ' '

Exception is taken to one instruction for the plaintiff, that it is misleading as to the circumstances to be shown, in order * to exempt the head of a family from liability for wages to one claimed to have sustained the relation of a member of it. That part of the instruction related to-a case resting upon an implied contract — we perceive no serious error in it — but this case rested upon an alleged express contract, positively testified to by several witnesses, and the instruction proceeds upon that hypothesis.

It was that, although under certain circumstances stated, the law would not hold the defendant liable for -wages without proof that he was to pay them, yet if there was an express and valid contract to pay them, he would be liable notwithstanding such circumstances. There can be no reasonable doubt that the jury found there was such a contract. Aside from this the ease presents only questions of fact, and it is not denied that there was much evidence to support the finding. A labored argument is made to show it did not amount to a preponderance. Of that the jury were the proper judges.

Judgment affirmed.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.