Howett v. Selby
Illinois Supreme Court
Howett v. Selby, 54 Ill. 151 (Ill. 1870)
Lawrence
Howett v. Selby
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the Court:
As between the mortgagee, Howett, and the mechanics in this case, the court decreed in conformity with the rule laid down in Crosby v. N. W. Manuf. Co. 48 Ill. 481, and in previous cases. As to the seventy-three dollars claimed by Howett for materials furnished, he can not complain that this claim was postponed to that of the mechanics who had filed their petitions, since he does not make this claim in his cross bill, and only sets it up in his answer. We find no error in the record.
Decree affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Edmund L. Howett v. Nicholas Selby
- Cited By
- 7 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- 1. Mechanic’s lien—rule of adjustment, as respects prior incumbrancers. In a proceeding to enforce a mechanic’s lien, to which a prior mortgagee was made a party defendant, the court found the proportion of the value of the premises at the time of the decree, which was added thereto by reason of the improvements out of which the mechanic’s lien arose, and then directed that out of the proceeds of a sale of the premises the proportion thereof, so ascertained, which would arise from the land without the improvements, should be first applied on the mortgage, aud the proportion arising from the enhanced value on account of the improvements should be paid on the mechanic’s lien; and any surplus of the latter fund to be applied to satisfy any balance due on the mortgage: Held, as between the mortgagee and the mechanics, the decree was in conformity with the rule laid down in Crosby v. N. W. Manufac. Co. 48 Ill. 481. 2. Cross bill—necessity thereof—relief on answer. And where the prior mortgagee in such case also claimed to have furnished materials for the improvements, it was proper that his claim should be postponed to that of the mechanic who had filed his petition, as the mortgagee did not make his claim in his cross bill, but only in his answer.