Western Reserve Life Insurance v. Ault
Western Reserve Life Insurance v. Ault
Opinion of the Court
Action by appellee to recover upon a life insurance policy issued by appellant upon the life of appellee’s decedent. The application for such policy was signed October 31, 1919. The policy, dated November 4, 1919, was delivered to the insured November 7, 1919. The insured died December 27, 1919. A trial was had before a jury and’ resulted in a verdict and judgment against appellant. The only error assigned relates to the action of the court in overruling the motion for a new trial.
The jury both by the general verdict and in answer to interrogatories found that the insured was not guilty of any fraud in making the statements and that such statements were substantially true. Nothing can be gained by entering into a discussion of the evidence. It suffices to say that the evidence is sufficient to sustain the verdict. Appellant undoubtedly had reason to believe it had been imposed upon and was justified in its action in refusing to pay the amount called for by the policy, but the evidence is not of such a character as.to make the question of fraud a matter of law. We cannot disturb the verdict on the ground that it is not sustained by the evidence or because it is contrary to law.
Appellant also complains of the action of the court in giving two certain instructions. These instructions are not subject to the objections urged against them. There was no error in giving either of them.
Judgment affirmed..
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.