Simms v. Kirk
Simms v. Kirk
Opinion of the Court
This action was instituted by Charles B. Kirk and his wife, Julia E. Kirk, against James F. Simms to quiet title to real estate. The trial court made a special finding of facts, stated conclusions of law thereon, and rendered judgment in favor of the plaintiffs.
It appears that one Nancy Evans (Simms) died testate; that, at the time of her death, she was, and for many years prior thereto, had been, the owner of the real estate involved in this action; that the plaintiffs purchased the real estate from her executor and received conveyances from the executor and legatees; and that the defendant James F. Simms claims to be the owner of the real estate as the surviving husband of Nancy Evans (Simms).
The court determined that the defendant never was the husband of Nancy Evans by virtue of any common-law marriage or any other kind of marriage; that he is in no way related to her; and that he is not entitled to inherit any part of her estate.
Counsel for the appellant concede, of course, that the ceremonial marriage was void; but they contend that there was a common-law marriage. The evidence abundantly sustains the decision of the trial court with respect to that feature. We have given the contention due consideration and we find nothing that would justify this court in disturbing the judgment of the trial court. Having reached this conclusion, other questions presented become immaterial. The fact
Judgment affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.