New York Life Insurance Co. v. Henriksen
New York Life Insurance Co. v. Henriksen
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting.
I would grant rehearing and affirm the trial court.
The trial court followed a Kentucky decision, National Life Ins. Co. v. Hood’s Admr. (1963) 264 Ky. 516, 94 S.W.2d 1022, and not the New York decision as relied upon by the majority.
The Kentucky decision reaches a more fair and equitable result and is based upon sounder reasoning.
The Insurance Company should not be entitled to a windfall since it retained the premiums and now refuses to carry out its part of the bargain.
Opinion of the Court
ON PETITION FOR REHEARING
This Court, on January 28,1981, reversed the judgment of the trial court and concluded that where the sole owner and beneficiary of a New York Life Insurance Company policy had murdered the insured, the insurer should be relieved of any liability on the policy proceeds. Ms. Lily Henriksen petitions for a rehearing of the appeal and urges that “if New York is not liable on the policy proceeds, it should be liable for all premiums paid in on the policy.”
Initially, we note that Ms. Henrik-sen, as administratrix of the estate of the insured, Chester 0. Henriksen, Jr., was the appellee in the initial appeal. In her representative capacity, she argued that the estate of the insured was entitled to receive the policy proceeds where there was no eligible beneficiary. In her petition for rehearing, Ms. Henriksen, in her individual capacity as owner’s designee,
Petition for rehearing is denied.
. In her capacity as administratrix, Ms. Henrik-sen also attempts to re-argue issues which have been previously passed on by this Court.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- NEW YORK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellant (Plaintiff Below), v. Chester O. HENRIKSEN, Sr., Lily A. Henriksen, Lily A. Myers, Gloria Cook, and Virginia Henriksen, Appellee (Defendants Below), Lily A. Henriksen as Administratrix of the Estate of Chester O. Henriksen, Jr., Appellee (Intervenor Defendants Below); Lily A. HENRIKSEN and Lily A. Henriksen as Administratrix of the Estate of Chester O. Henriksen, Jr., Appellee (Counterclaimants Below), v. NEW YORK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY, Appellant (Counterdefendant Below)
- Cited By
- 10 cases
- Status
- Published