BENNETT v. TYLER
Trial Court Opinion
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF INDIANA INDIANAPOLIS DIVISION MATTHEW BENNETT, ) ) Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) No. 1:20-cv-03016-TWP-MPB ) DUSHAN ZATECKY, ) CHRISTINA CONYERS, ) C. TYLER, ) BROGAN, ) BAKER, ) MEDICAL STAFF, ) ARNOLD, ) ) Defendants. ) ORDER DISMISSING AMENDED COMPLAINT AND PROVIDING FINAL OPPORTUNITY TO AMEND The Order of December 15, 2020, dismissed the complaint for failure to state a claim.
Dkt. 7. The plaintiff was given a period of time in which to attempt to cure the deficiencies noted in that Order. The plaintiff responded with an amended complaint, but the amended complaint does not cure the deficiencies noted in the Court's prior Order. The amended complaint does not allege that any of the defendants were aware of the risk the plaintiff's assailant posed to him before he was attacked.
The amended complaint states that the plaintiff was on protective custody status but was not housed in protective custody even though there were cells available to house him in the protective custody unit. The plaintiff alleges that his placement in a non-protective custody unit let to his assault by another inmate. These allegations may state a viable constitutional claim, but the plaintiff does not identify any defendant who was responsible for his placement outside the protective-custody unit.
Therefore, the amended complaint is dismissed. The plaintiff shall have through February 12, 2021, in which to file a second amended complaint. Because an amended complaint completely replaces the currently operative complaint, it must be a complete statement of the plaintiff's claims, including the factual basis of those claims, the individuals responsible for the harm to the plaintiff, and the relief sought by the plaintiff. See Beal v. Beller, 847 F.3d 897, 901 (7th Cir. 2017) ("For pleading purposes, once an amended complaint is filed, the original complaint drops out of the picture."). The second amended complaint should have the proper case number, 1:20-cv-03016-TWP-MPB, and the words "Second Amended Complaint” on the first page. If the plaintiff does not respond by the above deadline, this action will be dismissed for failure to state a claim without further notice.
IT ISSO ORDERED Date: 1/12/2021 O Wath ath Hon. Tanya Walton Pratt, Judge United States District Court Distribution: Southern District of Indiana MATTHEW BENNETT 988730 PENDLETON - CF PENDLETON CORRECTIONAL FACILITY Electronic Service Participant — Court Only
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.