Thompson v. Weaver
Thompson v. Weaver
Opinion of the Court
— Debt by the plaintiff against the defendant on a promissory note. Special demurrer to the declaration, and judgment for the defendant.
The declaration states that the defendant, on, &c., at, &c., made his promissory note, &c., by which he then and there promised to pay, twelve months after the date thereof, to the plaintiff, by the name and description of James Thompson, school-commissioner of the- county of Vermillion, or his successor in office, for the use of congressional township No. 14 north, range No. 9 west, the sum of 206 dollars and 8 cents, with interest, &c., for value received; yet the defendant, although often requested, has not paid, &c.
The first objection to the declaration is, that the sum demanded in the queritur is greater than the sum declared for. The plaintiff, in his declaration, complains that the defendant is indebted, &c., in the sum of 300 dollars, and then sets out the contract as above stated. There is no validity in this objection. • It is immaterial that the sums do not agree, and, indeed, it is not necessary to state the sum sued for in the queritur, and if it be erroneously stated it will not vitiate. Cozine el al. v. Tousey, 5 Blackf. 46.
The next objection is, that there is a variance between the declaration and the note sued on. That objection cannot prevail. The note, though if'is copied into the transcript, forms ho part of the record. The Circuit Court had not, nor has this Court, on a demurrer to the declaration, any means of judging whether there is a variance between the note and the declaration or not.
The point mainly relied on to support the judgment of the Circuit Court is, that this suit cannot be maintained in the name of the present plaintiff. It is argued that as the note is made payable to him as school-commissioner, for the use of
— The judgment is reversed with costs. Cause • remanded, &c.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Thompson, School Commissioner, &c. v. Weaver
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published