Polke v. Harper
Polke v. Harper
Opinion of the Court
The plaintiffs filed a petition for a mandamus against Harper, as trustee of a school district in Henry county, requiring him to appear and show cause why he should not, as such trustee, remove certain colored children from the school, &c. The petitioners alleged that they were white residents and inhabitants of, and taxpayers in the school district in question; that there was there at that time a common district school, open to all
In answer Harper made return, denying that the school taught by Miss Grey was a district school; denying that there was any district school under his supervision in the district; but on the contrary that Miss Grey's school was a private enterprise, setting out the contract between the teacher and her patrons, &c., and that he had no control over it, &c.
To this return the plaintiffs demurred; the Court overruled the demurrer; and on refusal to withdraw, the petition was dismissed at their costs. The petitioners bring the case to this Court.
The question whether the trustee of the district has a right, as such, to remove colored children from the district school, is not raised in the record. The return denies that there is any district school; and the demurrer admits what is alleged in the return, namely, that Miss Grey's school, the only one there, is a private school. With such a school Harper had, of course, no right to interfere. The facts in his return were sufficient, and the demurrer correctly overruled.
Per Curiam. — The judgment is affirmed with costs.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.