F. W. Cook Investment Co. v. Evansville Terminal Railway
F. W. Cook Investment Co. v. Evansville Terminal Railway
Opinion of the Court
Action by appellee to condemn real estate for use in constructing its street and interurban railroad. Appellee was duly organized under the voluntary associations act of March 9, 1901 (Acts 1901 p. 289), and the amendment or supplement thereto, approved March 7, 1903 (Acts 1903 p. 180).
The single question involved in this appeal is this: Is appellee a corporation authorized by law to exercise the right of eminent domain?
The first section of said act of March 9, 1901 (§4286 Burns 1908), which the act of 1903, supra, amends, provides that “ any number of persons, not less than three, may voluntarily associate themselves by written articles of association, signed and acknowledged by each person who may be a member at the time of organization, specifying,” etc., and stating what the articles of association shall contain. The second section of said act (§4287 Burns 1908) provides “ that such associations may be formed for one only of the following purposes.” This is followed by a list of more than thirty purposes for which such association may be formed. The twenty-eighth section (§4319 Burns 1908) provides that from the time the certificate is issued by the Secretary of State, and the articles recorded in the recorder’s office, such association “ shall be deemed and held to be a corporation, and shall have and possess all the rights, powers and privileges given to corporations by common law,” etc.
“ An act authorizing the formation of corporations under the provisions of £An act concerning the organization and perpetuity of voluntary associations, repealing all laws in conflict therewith, legalizing the organization of certain associations organized under former laws, and declaring an emergency/ approved March 9, 1901, for certain purposes not .therein named, and declaring an emergency.
“ Section 1. Be it enacted by the General Assembly of the State of Indiana, that any number of persons, not less than three, may voluntarily associate themselves into .a corporation in the manner set forth in an act entitled: ‘ An act concerning the organization and perpetuity of voluntary associations, repealing all laws in conflict therewith, legalizing the organization of certain associations organized under former laws, and declaring an emergency/ approved March 9, 1901, with all the rights and privileges granted by said act, and subject to all the provisions thereof, to promote, finance, construct, equip, rent and operate, in the State of Indiana or elsewhere, street and interurban railroads, and plants for the creation and distribution of electric and other heat, light and power, and in connection therewith to take, own, hold, negotiate, sell or otherwise dispose of and deal in stocks and securities of other companies, and to do all other things needful or connected therewith.” (Our italics.)
It is held in the case of County of Randolph v. Post (1876), 93 U. S. 502, 23 L. Ed. 957, that a corporation with authority to “ construct, complete and operate a railroad ” is not the less a railroad company because it is also a coal, or a mining, or a furnace, or a manufacturing company. Seymour v. City of Tacoma (1893), 6 Wash. 147, 32 Pac. 1077.
5. Corporations may also be formed for the maintenance of cemeteries, under the act of 1879 (Acts 1879 [s. s.] p. 84, §4433 Burns 1908), or under the voluntary associations act (§4291, supra). No general power to exercise the right of eminent domain is given by any provision of the manufacturing and mining act. Companies organized thereunder to do a business of a gwasi-public character, such as water-works, distribution of oil, gas, heat, light, power, etc., are given the right to condemn by special provision.
The legislative sense is made even plainer in other acts relating to the same subject. In conferring the power upon oil companies, the language of the act is “that all companies, corporations and voluntary associations now organized under the laws of the State of Indiana, or which may hereafter be organized thereunder,” shall have the right, etc. §5159 Burns 1908, Acts 1897 p. 263, §1.
With respect to gas companies enjoying the right, the act of 1907 (Acts 1907 p. 340, §5144 Burns 1908), clearly recognizing that such a corporation may exist under more than one law, disposes of the subject thus: “That whenever any corporation or voluntary association, organized under the laws of the State of Indiana, or which may hereafter be incorporated thereunder for the purpose of manufacturing” and distributing gas, etc., desires to exercise the right of eminent domain, it may do so under the act of 1889 (Acts 1889 p. 22).
It, therefore, seems only material that an applicant for the right under discussion shall be able to show that it is a duly organized corporation, authorized by some law of Indiana to exist, and to do the things declared in its articles.
“ Railroad companies are companies or associations organized for the purpose of constructing, maintaining and operating railroads.” 1 Elliott, Railroads §1.
But while there seems no doubt of appellee’s right to seek the voluntary associations act of 1903 for organization purposes, it is very clear that having adopted as its business and purpose of organization the promotion, construction, equipment and operation of a street and interurban railroad — a business specially regulated by another and different statute— it thereby assumes, and subjects itself to, all the additional duties and responsibilities imposed by the street and interurban statutes as fully and in all respects as if its organization had been under the latter statutes. Such an organization can find no refuge in the voluntary associations act from a burden, or delinquency, under the street and interurban acts.
Judgment affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- F. W. Cook Investment Company v. Evansville Terminal Railway
- Status
- Published