VanHorn v. United States Postal Service
Trial Court Opinion
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF KANSAS
JENIFER A. VANHORN, ) )
Plaintiff, ) ) v. ) Case No. 21-1067-DDC-GEB )
UNITED STATES POSTAL SERVICE, ) )
Defendant. ) )
ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO STAY AND
RESCINDING PROVISIONAL APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL
This employment discrimination case is before the Court on two issues: 1) Defendant’s Unopposed Motion to Stay Issuance of an Initial Order, Discovery, and other scheduling (ECF No. 14), and 2) the provisional appointment of attorney Jennifer M. Hill as counsel for Plaintiff. (See Mem. and Order, ECF No. 5.)
I. Motion to Stay (ECF No. 14)
Defendant asks the Court for an order staying all deadlines in this case, including the issuance of an initial order, discovery, planning conference, initial disclosures and scheduling of deadlines, pending the ruling on Defendant’s recent partial motion to dismiss. (Motion to stay, ECF No. 14 at 1; Motion to dismiss; ECF No. 12.) The motion to stay indicates defense counsel conferred with Ms. Hill, who had no objection to such a stay of scheduling. (Id.)
Although the motion to stay may be decided as unopposed, in spite of the lack of objection, the Court independently undertook a review of the motion. On review of this case, the motion, and related authority, in its broad discretion1 the Court finds a stay of scheduling appropriate at this time. Although Defendant’s motion to dismiss does not seek dismissal of this case in its entirety, the resolution of the motion has the potential to significantly narrow the issues remaining for discovery.2 Likewise, this potential narrowing of the issues will assist Plaintiff in pursuing this action as a pro se litigant. (See discussion below.) A stay of deadlines and discovery will conserve time and expense both for the Court and the parties until the resolution of the motion to dismiss clarifies precisely which claims will survive.3
II. Provisional Appointment of Counsel
Pursuant to the Memorandum and Order (ECF No. 5) which provisionally appointed Jennifer Hill to represent Plaintiff, the Court undertook a review of Ms. Hill’s limited appointment.
As requested by the Court, Ms. Hill has completed her initial investigation of this matter. Ms. Hill’s investigation included a review of the pleadings, in-person consultation with plaintiff Jenifer A. VanHorn, and review of hundreds of pages of documentation.
Following Ms. Hill’s thorough review, the Court finds that Ms. Hill’s investigation assists the Court in making its determination under the third (the merit of Plaintiff’s claims) and fourth (Plaintiff’s ability to present her case) factors of the Tenth Circuit decision in Castner v. Colorado Springs Cablevision.4
After careful consideration of the pleadings, Ms. Hill’s investigation, and the relevant factors in Castner, the Court finds that Plaintiff Jenifer VanHorn has the capacity to present the case without counsel at this stage. Although the Court has concerns regarding the merit of Plaintiff’s claims at this time, the Court recognizes that “its perception of the merits and other factors relevant to the issue of appointment of counsel may vary”5 as the case progresses. Postponing a decision to appoint counsel allows the Court to gain more information about both the merits of Plaintiff’s claims and her continued ability to present this case.6 For this reason, Plaintiff’s request for counsel— although provisionally granted for the purpose of investigating the Castner factors—is now denied without prejudice to later review.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that Jennifer M. Hill has fulfilled the purpose of her provisional appointment based upon her investigation and consultation with Plaintiff. She is relieved entirely from further professional obligations and duties arising under the previous order.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Plaintiff Jenifer VanHorn’s request for appointment of counsel is DENIED without prejudice.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the issuance of an initial order, discovery, planning conference, initial disclosures and scheduling of deadlines are hereby stayed pending resolution of the Motion to Dismiss (ECF No. 12). Following decision on that Motion, in the event this matter proceeds in any fashion, an initial order will issue expeditiously, establishing deadlines for the progress of this case.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Dated at Wichita, Kansas this 23rd day of August 2021. s/ Gwynne E. Birzer
GWYNNE E. BIRZER
United States Magistrate Judge
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.