Eaves v. Estes
Cases that cite this one
30 later published cases cite this decision. The 25 that cite it most often are listed here.
- Bromich v. Burkholder (Kan. 1916)
- Murray Co. v. Simmons (Tex. Comm'n App. 1921)
- Brockman Equipment Leasing, Inc. v. Sowell (In re Crew's Chrysler-Plymouth, Inc.) (United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Kansas 1980)
- Thuma v. Granada Hotel Corp. (Ill. App. Ct. 1933)
- Smith v. Holland Furnace Co. (Kan. 1929)
- Abramson v. Penn (Md. 1928)
- Boeringa v. Perry (Wash. 1917)
- Cox v. . Lighting Co. (N.C. 1909)
- Cox v. New Bern Lighting & Fuel Co. (N.C. 1909)
- In re Equalization Appeal of Coffeyville Resources Nitrogen Fertilizers (Kan. Ct. App. 2018)
- Flyge v. Flynn (Nev. 1946)
- Finnegan v. Ihinger (Kan. 1939)
- Compton v. W. F. & J. F. Barnes Lumber Co. (Tex. App. 1936)
- Lasch v. Columbus Heating & Ventilating Co. (Ga. 1932)
- Gafford Lumber & Grain Co. v. Eaves (Kan. 1923)
- Liddell Co. v. Cork (S.C. 1922)
- McFarlane v. Foley (Ind. Ct. App. 1901)
- Hertzberg v. Witte (Tex. App. 1899)
- Hurxthal's v. Hurxthal's Heirs (W. Va. 1898)
- Ice, Light & Water Co. v. Lone Star Engine & Boiler Works (Tex. App. 1897)
- Winslow v. Bromich (Kan. 1894)
- Marshall v. Bacheldor (Kan. 1891)
- Binkley v. Forkner (Ind. 1889)
- Henkle v. Dillon (Or. 1888)
- Harkey v. Cain (Tex. 1887)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The defendants in error manufactured a steam-engine for Philip Koehler, and before it left their shop took a chattel mortgage upon it for the payment of the purchase-money, with a stipulation in the mortgage, of their right to take possession of the engine whenever they might deem themselves insecure, or in default of payment, and remove the same from the mill, whether it should be attached to the realty or otherwise. Eaves, the plaintiff in error, having become the purchaser of the mill and lots under a foreclosure of a mortgage thereon made prior to the placing the engine therein, claims the engine as a part of the freehold, as against the rights of defendants in error as mortgagees. Eaves had actual and constructive notice of the existence of the mortgagp-^nd^ckúmlñff^d^ when he bought the property, The district court held that the defendants in error were entitled to the engine under their mortgage, and this decision presents the only question in the case. As a general rule, improvements on real property inure to the mortgagee as part of his security - but whether any given piece of property becomes so attached to the freehold as to-make it a part thereof, is frequently a question of great difficulty. From the very nature of things it is oftentimes most embarrassing to determine when a piece of property, personal in its original character, becomes a fixture by reason of its use in connection with the freehold. And the best guides for the determination of such questions, are, to ascertain whether the property is actually annexed to the freehold, to consider the use to which it is appropriated in connection with the freehold, and what was. the intention of the party — whether it was his purpose to make it a permanent accession to the freehold, or otherwise, “this intention being inferred from the nature of the article affixed, the relation and situation of the party making the annexation, the structure and mode of annexation, and the purpose or use for which the annexation has been made.” Teaff v. Hewitt, 1 Ohio St., 530. Testing
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.