McCubbin v. City of Atchison
McCubbin v. City of Atchison
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
On the 9th of January 1872 the city of Atchison made a contract with D. C. O’Keefe to grade
“Atchison, Kas., June 1st, 1872. For value received I hereby sell and assign to E. S. McCubbin, of the money coming to me on my contract with the city of Atchison for grading Spring street in said city of Atchison, the sum of $450, more or less, as soon as said work shall be completed according to said contract with said city; and I hereby authorize the proper city authorities to pay such sum to said McCubbin. D. C. O’Keeee.”
In February 1872, and before any work had been done, O’Keefe had given two orders on the city on account of this contract, (one for the sum of $125, and the other for $18.25.) These orders were accepted by no one, but simply filed with . the clerk or treasurer. In August 1872, and after the work had been completed, certain garnishee proceedings
By offering the plaintiff judgment, providing he would remit the amount of these orders, the court in effect overruled all other grounds for a new trial. Should these orders have been deducted from the amount of the verdict? O’Keefe testified that when he turned the contract over to plaintiff, and signed the instrument hereinbefore set forth, it was with the agreement that the two orders should be first paid, and that the balance only should go to plaintiff. This plaintiff denied, and testified that he knew nothing about these orders, and that he was to finish the work and receive the entire pay. The work having been done in pursuance of the contract, to the acceptance of the officials designated in the contract, the city was bound to pay some one the contract-price. There is
Reference
- Full Case Name
- R. S. McCubbin v. The City of Atchison
- Cited By
- 8 cases
- Status
- Published