In re Bartholomew
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Emerson-Brantingham Implement Co. v. Fenimore (Kan. 1931)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
Lucy C. E. Gay brought her action against George W. Bartholomew, to recover upon a promissory note and foreclose a mortgage given to secure the same. The petition set forth that the note had become due and the mortgage subject to foreclosure by reason of the failure of the defendant to pay the semi-annual installment of interest when, by the terms of the note, the same became due. The defendant answered, pleading payment of interest, and therefore that nothing was due; to which answer, plaintiff replied by a general denial. Neither the petition nor the answer was verified. The case thereupon stood for trial upon the issue made by the pleadings, whether the interest had, in fact, been paid. The plaintiff filed her motion to strike the answer from the files as untrue in fact, and therefore a sham. It was sought to support this motion by the deposition or affidavit of the petitioner. He refused to testify before the notary public when his deposition was attempted to be taken; and for this refusal was committed to the custody of the sheriff, W. W. Hays, as keeper of the common jail, for contempt. He alleges that he is unlawfully restrained of his liberty, and this proceeding has been brought by him to obtain his discharge.
The principal question is, whether the defendant can be required to furnish an affidavit or his deposition to support a motion to strike out his answer upon the ground that it is a sham only. A sham answer is one good in form, but false in fact and not pleaded in good faith. In several of the states, as for instance, New York, Indiana and California, the civil code provides that sham and irrelevant answers may be stricken out upon such terms as the court may in its discretion impose. The code of this state contains no such provision. In this state a petition does not have to be verified, and the answer needs no verification, unless it is intended to put in issue the
- While we shall not go so far in this decision as to say that an answer which is false in fact, and therefore a sham, may not, under some circumstances, be stricken out, yet we do not think it good practice to permit a motion to be filed to strike out an answer as a sham, and then compel the defendant to make affidavit or give a deposition to be used upon the motion. On the part of a plaintiff, the answer may be claimed to be
We do not think the petitioner is required to give his affidavit or deposition to be used upon the motion to strike his answer from the files. He will therefore be discharged, with costs.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.