McIntyre v. Iliff
McIntyre v. Iliff
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
This is an original proceeding in quo warranto to try the right to the office of probate judge of Linn county. Ever since the organization of the state the statute has required the election of probate judges for the full term of the office to be held in the even-numbered years. At the general election in November, 1900, one J. Q. Kennedy was elected probate judge of Linn county. He qualified and entered oh the duties of the office, but soon thereafter died. The governor appointed the defendant, J. M. Iliff, to fill the vacancy. He likewise qualified and entered into the office. The authority for this appointment is section
The action cannot be maintained. Section 2628 of the General Statutes of 1901 reads as follows':
“All vacancies in any state or county office, and in the supreme or district courts, unless otherwise provided for by law, shall be filled by appointment from the governor, until the next general election after such vacancy occurs, when such vacancy shall be filled by election.”
The constitution (art. 4, § 2) reads : “General elections shall-be held annually on the Tuesday succeeding the first Monday in November.” Notwithstanding the recent enactment of the statute providing for biennial elections (Laws 1901, ch. 176 ;■ Gen. Stat: 1901, §§ 2751-2755), the Tuesday succeeding the first Monday in November is still a general-election day. It must be such under the above-quoted constitutional provision, but, save as to those offices the time for the filling of which is prescribed by the- constitution, it is competent for the legislature to determine what officers shall
However, he is also an officer of the class called “judicial,” and it must be recalled that, as to vacancies in judicial offices, the constitution (art. 3, §11), above quoted, makes special provision. That provision is for appointment “until the next regular election.” If, therefore, there is any difference in meaning between “next regular election,” as used in the constitution, and “next general election,” as used in the statute, the constitutional meaning, not the statutory one, must be allowed. There is a difference in meaning. “General election” means that election held generally throughout the state in November of each year for such officers as the constitution ordains or the statute provides shall then be chosen. (Art. 4,
The judgment is for the defendant.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- W. E. McIntyre v. J. M. Iliff
- Cited By
- 10 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- SYLLABUS BY THE COURT. 1. Office and Officers — Terms of Appointed Judicial Officers. The phrase “until the next regular election,” as used in section 11 of article 3 of the constitution, providing for appointments to fill vacancies in judicial offices, means until the next regular election held at the time fixed by law for the filling of the particular class of judicial offices to which the appointment was made. 2. - Term of Appointed Probate Judge. The time of the regular election to fill the office of probate judge has always been, as fixed by statute, in the even-numbered years; held, therefore, that upon the death of an incumbent of such office, occurring more than thirty days before the regular biennial election, and an appointment to fill the vacancy, the appointee holds until such election.