Supreme Court of Kansas, 1905

Hill v. Maxwell

Hill v. Maxwell
Supreme Court of Kansas · Decided March 11, 1905 · No. 13 · Burch
71 Kan. 72; 79 P. 1088; 1905 Kan. LEXIS 92
Hill v. Maxwell

Cases that cite this one

7 later published cases cite this decision.

This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Burch, J.:

This evidence was amply sufficient to show a settlement of a disputed claim, and to show a consideration for accepting a less sum of money than the seller claimed he was entitled to receive. (Neely v. Thomp*74son, 68 Kan. 193, 75 Pac. 117, and authorities cited in the opinion.)

In the course of the trial testimony was given concerning a lost memorandum of the sale, made at the time of the first negotiations, signed by the plaintiff and delivered to the defendant. The terms of this writing were not admitted by the defendant, but, conceding it to contain all the elements of a complete contract expressing the plaintiff’s view, still the defendant’s evidence was competent.

In order to overthrow the plaintiff’s case the defendant undertook to show a former controversy over the price of this land, and a binding settlement. The controversy arose out of an attack the defendant had made upon the terms of the written memorandum on a certain occasion antedating the suit. The validity of that attack at the time it was made was immaterial. The form of action and the character of evidence which would have been necessary at that time to sustain it in court were immaterial; but the fact that when he paid for the land he had impeached the written memorandum of sale was material. The defendant did not seek in this case to contradict a writing. He merely undertook to prove there had been a previous dispute in which he had asserted its untruthfulness, and had insisted upon a state of facts incompatible with it, against the assertions and insistence of the plaintiff to the contrary. This furnished a foundation for the settlement and for the defense in this action.

It is urged that the oral features of the settlement ran counter to the statute of frauds, and that the original written agreement could not be modified by an oral one, ineffective for that reason. The oral arrangement, however, was fully performed by the payment of the price on one side and the delivery of the deed on the Qther. Hence, the statute of frauds was fully satisfied. When the parties met to settle *75they could have agreed orally, had they so desired, upon a sale including only half of the land at ten dollars per acre, despite the previous contract, and upon performance both parties would have been bound.

"It is .well settled, that the terms of a written contract cannot be varied by any previously executed contract, written or parol, nor by any contemporaneous parol contract. It is equally well settled, that the terms of a ’written contract may be varied, modified, waived, annulled, or wholly set aside, by any subsequently executed contract, whether such subsequently executed contract be in writing or in parol.” (Todd v. Allen, 18 Kan. 543, 545. See, also, 29 A. & E. Encycl. of L. 829.)

There is, of course, another side to this case, but the defendant had a clear right to the opinion of a jury upon it.

The motion to dismiss is overruled on the authority of Butler v. Scott, 68 Kan. 512, 75 Pac. 496, jurisdiction having been reserved for the entire time within which the parties might have made and served the case and suggested amendments.

The judgment of the district court is reversed, with direction to grant the defendant a new trial.

All the Justices concurring.

Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.