Citizens' National Bank v. Bank of Commerce
Citizens' National Bank v. Bank of Commerce
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
The plaintiff in error insists that the transaction in which the certificates were deposited with Minturn, in trust for the secürity of the inter-pleading bank, amounted to a pledge of the certificates, and gave a right to them superior to any which could thereafter be acquired by an attachment issued in a .suit.against the pledgor.
The . Bank of Commerce claims that whatever right the Citizens’ bank may have acquired to the certificates, its right to the tangible property represented thereby was inferior to the lien acquired thereon by an actual seizure thereof by a writ of attachment in favor of one who had no knowledge or notice of the pledge.
We understand that when- personal property is pledged the pledgee acquires a right thereto which is superior to any right that can thereafter be given by the pledgor or be acquired by a subsequent attachment issued in an action against him. (22 A. & E. Encycl. of L. 867, 868, and notes; Bank v. Harkness, 42 W. Va. 156.) The assignment and delivery of the certificate constitutes a delivery of the property represented thereby. (22 A. & E. Encycl. of L. 856.) In the second edition of Jones on Pledges and Collateral Security, section 37, it is said:
“A delivery of a document of title, which serves to put the pledgee in possession of the goods, is equivalent to an actual delivery of them.”
This question was discussed and authorities were collected in the case of Bank v. Harkness, 42 W. Va. 156. (See, also, Continental Nat. Bank v. Eliot Nat. Bank, 7 Fed. 369.) The great weight of authority
The judgment of the district court is reversed, with direction to overrule the demurrer to the interplea and proceed in accordance with the views herein expressed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- The Citizens' National Bank of Fort Scott v. The Bank of Commerce
- Cited By
- 8 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- SYLLABUS BY THE COURT. 1. ' Pledges — Stock—Assignment and Delivery of Certificate— Change of Possession. The assignment and actual delivery to another of a certificate of stock in a joint stock company, by the owner thereof, for the purpose of pledging the property represented by such certificate as collateral security for the payment of a debt of such owner, is sufficient to effectuate a change of the possession of such property from the owner to the holder of the assigned certificate when such property is not itself susceptible of delivery. 2. - Priority of Liens — Pledgee—Attaching Creditor. In such a case the holder of the assigned certificate will have a right to the property, for the purposes of such pledge, superior and prior to the rights subsequently acquired by an attaching creditor. 3. -- Trusts and Trustees. A pledge to secure a debt may be made in trust to a third person for such purpose with the same effect as if made directly to the creditor. 4. -Record. The law relating to the registration of chattel mortgages has no application to pledges.