Brown v. Ammann
Brown v. Ammann
Opinion of the Court
W. T. Brown, as administrator of the estate of Herman Ammann, deceased, brought this action to recover from Joseph Ammann, one of the sons of the deceased, the sum of $700, and interest, which
In answer the appellant admitted the receipt of $500 as a loan for which he was to pay seven per cent interest ; that no time was fixed by the verbal agreement to repay the debt; that more than three years had elapsed since the last payment, and that the action was barred by the three-year statute of limitations. The answer failed to allege that any demand for payment had been made by the administrator or by the deceased more than three years before the commencement of the action, or to allege any other fact which fixed any time when the repayment became due. The answer failed to state, and the evidence of the appellant, taken as true, did not establish any defense to the cause of action, but, on the other.hand, tended to admit and establish a cause of action.
The only controversy seems to have been whether the money was received by the appellant in trust, to be held for the use and benefit of his father, or whether it was a loan by the father to him.
The case was tried to the court and the court -found that the appellant was indebted to the estate in the sum of $600. It does not appear from the abstract that there was any finding as to whether the money was received as a trust or as a loan, and under the pleadings it does not appear to make any difference.
The judgment is affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- W. T. Brown, as Administrator, etc. v. Joseph Ammann
- Status
- Published