Dessery v. Western Union Telegraph Co.
Dessery v. Western Union Telegraph Co.
Opinion of the Court
The opinion of the court was delivered by
The plaintiff commenced this action to recover damages from the defendant for failing to transmit money by telegram. Judgment was rendered for the plaintiff for actual and punitive damages, and the defendant appeals.
On October 27, 1918, the plaintiff was a soldier at Camp
The leading case is Dakota Cent. Tel. Co. v. South Dakota, 250 U. S. 163, where it was held that state' control over intrastate telephone rates ceased with the exercise by the president of his authority under the joint resolution of July 16, 1918. (Part 1, 40 U. S. Stat. at Large, Ch. 154.) That rule has been followed in the regulation of intrastate railroad freight rates (Northern Pac. Ry. Co. v. North Dakota, 250 U. S. 135) ; in actions against a telephone company for injuries sustained by an employee while working for the company (Mitchell v. Cumberland Telephone & Telegraph Co., 221 S.W.547 [Ky.]); and in actions for damages caused by delay in the transmission of telegrams. (Canidate v. Western Union Tel. Co., 85 So. 10 [Ala.] ; Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Glover, 86 So. 154 [Ala.] ; Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Davis, 218 S. W. 833 [Ark.] ; Foster v. Western Union Telegraph Co., 219 S. W. 107 [Mo.] ; Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Conditt, 223 S. W. 234 [Tex.] ; Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Wallace, — S. W. — [Tex., Feb. 10, 1920, not yet reported]; White v. United
It necessarily followis that the judgment must be reversed, and that judgment must be rendered for the defendant. It is so ordered.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Jennings R. Dessery v. The Western Union Telegraph Company
- Cited By
- 1 case
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- SYLLABUS BY THE COURT. Telegram — Fwilu/re to Transmit Money by Telegram — Telegraph Line Under Control of Government — Company Not Liable for Damages. The Western Union Telegraph Company is not liable for damages caused by the failure to transmit money by telegram over the Western Union lines during the time that the property of the company was under the control of the government of the United States under the joint resolution adopted by Congress July 16, 1918, and the proclamation of the president issued thereunder July 22, 1918, and the order of the postmaster-general issued August 1, 1918.