State v. Hurlbert

Supreme Court of Kansas
State v. Hurlbert, 118 Kan. 362 (Kan. 1925)
234 P. 945; 1925 Kan. LEXIS 186
Dawson

State v. Hurlbert

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the court was delivered by

Dawson, J.:

Defendant was convicted of the felony denounced in R. S. 21-907. The proof showed that defendant had committed this abomination with an eleven-year-old boy, serving alternately as actor and catamite, as Zeus and Ganymede.

The sole error urged is that the evidence which proved a penetration per os was not sufficient to sustain a conviction. It is argued that the statute is an inheritance of the common law, where carnal penetration per anum was the particular form of abomination which shocked the sensibilities of our forefathers and fell into their category of crimes.

There is a plethora of juristic learning in the lawbooks on this morbid subject for all who choose to pursue it, with illuminating sidelights touching such depravities in Holy Writ and in Greek and Cretan mythology; but this court is content to rest on the fair import of the language of our own statute, which reads:

“Proof of actual penetration into the body shall be sufficient proof to sustain an indictment or information for rape, or for the crime against nature.” (R. S. 62-1417.)

The court holds that proof of any actual, lecherous penetration of the body of a man, woman or beast, per os, per anum, or in any other manner contrary to nature, will sustain a conviction.

We do not overlook the decisions which hold a different view. (State v. Johnson, 44 Utah 18, 137 Pac. 18, and citations.) But without attempting to analyze possible differences in statutes which *363may justify different judicial conclusions, this court finds itself in excellent company on this question. See Glover v. State, 179 Ind. 459, 45 L. R. A., n. s., 473, and citations and notes; Note to Kinnan v. State, 86 Neb. 234, in 27 L. R. A., n. s., 478; State v. Start, 65 Ore. 178, 46 L. R. A., n. s., 266, 132 Pac. 512.

The judgment is affirmed.

Reference

Full Case Name
The State of Kansas v. Wayne Hurlbert
Cited By
7 cases
Status
Published