Hickman v. Grimes
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This was a bill filed by Benjamin Grimes against James Hickman, jun. and his father James Hickman, sen. to obtain a conveyance of 100 acres of land, which James Hickman, jun. had given his obligation to convey to Grimes, in consideration of the latter having undertaken to build for him a framed house of certain dimensions. Grimes alleges that he had nearly completed the house, and would have finished it, but for the failure of James Hickman, jun. te
As the answer of James Hickman, jun. admits the execution of the obligation by him for the conveyance of the 100 acres of the land, for the consideration in the bill mentioned, and as the evidence satisfactorily shews that the greater part of the work was done, and that the whole would have been completed but for the failure of the the defendant to furnish such materials as he was bound to do; it is plain that the complainant has shewn himself entitled to relief against him. But we are clearly of opinion that the decree against James Hickman, sen. is erroneous and cannot be sustained. It is not alleged that he had ted to his son a covenant or deed, binding himself to convey the land in controversy, and a mere promise to convey, founded upon no other consideration, than that of blood or relationship, we apprehend is not sufficient to justify a cree for its specific execution. Where such a tion is united to the efficacy of a deed, and the contract is executory, its execution may be decreed by a court of equity, as was held by this court in the case of M’Intire and Hughes, 4 Bibb.
But we are aware of no case in which it has been decided that a promise to give or convey land, founded upon the consideration of consanguinity alone, could be enforced in a court of equity. Such a consideration would certainly not be Sufficient to support an action of assumpsit, and it *s a general rule that if an action at law will not lie upon a contract to recover damages for its breach, a court of equity will not decree its specific execution. Besides, it is in-ferable from ali the cases, which have any bearing upon this point, that a contract without being by deed, founded
The decree must be reversed with costs, and the cause remanded, that a decree may be entered not inconsistent with the foregoing opinion.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.