M'Cracken's Heirs v. Stayton
M'Cracken's Heirs v. Stayton
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an appeal taken by the plaintiffs in an action of ejectment from a judgment rendered in favor of the defendant.
The only point made in the case, relates to the manner of ascertaining the position of a lost corner of the survey un-4er which the plaintiffs claim. The survey is one of a
Without enquiring what ought to be the rule of decision in a dase destitute of all evidence tending to shew that the *ine a surveJ had been originally run, and the corner made, beyond the distance described in the patent, we can no hesitation in saying that, under the circumstances °f this case, the circuit court erred in deciding that the third line of the plaintiff’s survey could not extend beyond the patent distance. The call for distance, as it terminates before the line enters the- field, is manifestly incompatible with the call/or the corner in the field, and, according to the repeated decisions of this court, as the latter is a call for an object of sense, it must control the former which is not so. {⅛ even jellgjb of the line, as described in the survey, when compared with the actual admeasurement on the ground, affords a presumption that the láse, when originally run, extended some distance into the field. Ror, by the call !o cross the creek at 150 poles from the third cerner, and-to run in the whole length 300 poles, it is cer-‘ implied that the line was extended 15Ó poles after posing theicreeky but the distance from the third corner to the creek instead of 150 poles, is found, by actual admea-surement, to be 160, and to make the line terminate at the eo(^ °* poles would therefore be extending it only 140 poles from the creek, instead of 150, as is implied in the
The judgment must be reversed with costs, and the cause be remanded for new proceedings to be had, not inconsistent with the foregoing opinion.
Absent, Jonas Kgwah.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.