Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1839

Arnold's v. Crooks

Arnold's v. Crooks
Court of Appeals of Kentucky · Decided April 22, 1839 · Robertson
38 Ky. 37; 8 Dana 37; 1839 Ky. LEXIS 12

Arnold's v. Crooks

Opinion of the Court

Chief Justice Robertson

delivered the Opinion of the Court.

There is no law authorizing a judgment for costs, as costs, in a common law suit against an executor who sued on a cause of action which had accrued to his testator, and not to himself; and an appeal from a Justice to the Circuit Court is, in this respect, like other cases. The statute of 1812 (1 Stat. Law, 675,) applies only to the Court of Appeals; and moreover, does not apply to a judgment for costs, but only prescribes the mode of taking supersedeas and appeal bonds. Wherefore it seems to this Court, that there should have been no judgment whatever for costs in this case; and even had any such judgment been proper, it should have been de bonis iestatoris, and not, as it was, de bonis propriis.

Judgment for costs therefore reversed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.