Kinsolving v. Pierce
Kinsolving v. Pierce
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion of the court.
The only question presented for our determination in this case is, can the purchaser of a widow’s right of dower, in lands which were alienated by her husband in his lifetime, maintain an action in his own name, against the alienee in possession, who is holding and claiming the lands as his own?
The conveyance of the widow’s right of dower was executed in May, 1854. The husband’s deeds to his alienee had been made many years previously.
The law prohibits the sale and conveyance of any lands, or the pretended right or title to the same, of which any other person, at the time of such sale, has adverse possession, and declares every such sale and conveyance absolutely null and void. (Revised Statutes, page 164.)
It is however, contended, that the possession of the vendee of the husband is not adverse to the dower-claim of the widow of his vendor, that the rights of both are derived from the same source, and that he holds the land subject to her right of dower.
The purchaser from the husband may by express contract, purchase subject to the wife’s contingent right of dower, and in such a case his holding would be presumed to be consistent with the terms of his purchase until he manifested his intention, by open and notorious acts, after her right accrued, to hold in opposition to it, and thus render his possession adverse; or, in the absence of such an express,agreement, he may, after the death of the husband, recognize the right of the widow’ to dower, and thus make his possession amicable, by holding subject to her claim.
But where, as in the present case, he denies her right, and claims and holds the land as his own, his possession is not only adverse to his vendor, but to alll persons claiming under him. The widow’s right
In our opinion, therefore, the purchase in this case is expressly embraced by the statute against champerty, and is obviously against the policy of the law.
Wherefore, the judgment of the circuit court dismissing the plaintiff’s petition is affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.