Bland v. Adams Express Co.
Bland v. Adams Express Co.
Opinion of the Court
delivered the opinion oe the court :
To a petition by Arthur Bland against the “ Adams Express Company,” charging the non-delivery, according to consignment, of a package containing $2,279, confided by him, at the city of Louisville, on the 10th day of May, 1862, to said company, as a common carrier, to carry from said city to his consignee at the city of Nashville, it filed an answer alleging that its agent forthwith placed the said package with all its said contents in its iron safe on the railroad train then departing from Louisville to Nashville; that, on the same day, John Morgan and his band of Confederate soldiers, on the way, near Cave City, attacked the train, burnt most of the cars, and, by irresistible armed force, robbed the safe of the said package and all its contents; and that no portion of the money so abstracted had been rescued or restored. These facts having been sufficiently proved, the circuit judge, to whom the law and the facts were submitted, dismissed the petition. And this appeal seeks the reversal of that judgment.
Public policy, and consequently the law, holds common carriers to a peculiar responsibility, extremely stringent, admitting'no excuse for the loss of goods except an act of God or of a public enemy, which could not, by any proper care or available force, have been overcome or averted. No other human force than that of a public enemy will exonerate the carrier, because, otherwise, he might fraudulently muster or combine with a force to rob himself.
Wherefore, the judgment is affirmed.
NOTE.
Chief Justice Bullitt was removed during the Winter Term, 1864, and Hon. William Sampson was appointed to fill the vacancy until the August election, 1865.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.