Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1869

Hall v. O'Donnell

Hall v. O'Donnell
Court of Appeals of Kentucky · Decided September 30, 1869 · Robertson
3 Ky. Op. 495; 1869 Ky. LEXIS 493

Hall v. O'Donnell

Opinion of the Court

Opinion of the Court by

Judge Robertson:

The mechanic’s lien asserted by the appellant as a sub-contractor is unavailing for want of the written notice required by the statute. And there is no proof of the alleged promise.

Nor does it sufficiently appear that after payments to the under*496takers and. most of the subordinates, any surplus demandable for work or material remains unappropriated.

Carlisle & O’Hara, for appellant. Fisks, for appellee.

The $1,000 charged by the petition to have been a loan, must be adjudged to have been a payment. Positive testimony and intrinsic probability authorize no other conclusion.

Wherefore, the judgment dismissing the petition is affirmed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.