Opinion of the Court by

The alleged assignment of the three shares of stock in the Louisville & Nashville railroad company to appellee purports to have been made and bears date prior to the date of the judgments of appellants, and it is not alleged in any of the petitions that it was ante-dated, nor that their debts for which said judgments were rendered, were in existence before said assignment was made, it is not averred that it was made with any improper motive, or fraudulent design, nor without consideration; the assignment is in the hand writing of the decedent— And although the legal title to the stock did not pass thereby still appellee acquired an equitable right which is prior in time, and must prevail over appellants.

Wherefore the judgment is affirmed.