Robards v. Daviess
Robards v. Daviess
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
The note sued.on is made payable “to the order of Ann M. Daviess and the children of Theo. H. Davies's,” and in the deed to the land in which Mrs. Daviess united, for one installment of which said note was executed, it is recited with care and par
The deceased, after placing the money beyond the reach of the husband and his creditors, provides that Mrs, Daviess may invest in one way only, viz., “in real estate, in a house for herself, and the children of said Theo. H. Daviess.” Her control is thus limited to the permanent investment of the money to .one object, and that not to her benefit alone, but to that <pf the other beneficiaries named, in real estate which would be permanent, and exist when she should be gone; and then the disposition provided for “is the same that the law would make of the land if she could have had dower allotted therein.” She would have held it only during her life, and then it would have passed to those for whom provision is made in the deed.
This deed was written by a lawyer, was evidently prepared with great care, and, as written, provides for all those who had the strongest claims on the grantor’s bounty, first the wife for •life,- as we understand it, and then their children, with the privileg-e of the children to share the house with the mother in their minority. This, in our opinion, is the proper interpretation of the instrument; and the draftsman proves that it expresses the intention of the parties, and we see no grounds which will allow the beneficent purposes of the grantor to be frustrated.
For the foregoing reasons we can not concur with the court below in the judgment of November, 1872, adjudging to- Mrs. Ann M. Daviess the whole of the debt sued for, and awarding her execution. But said judgment is reversed, on the appeal of the children of Theo. H. Daviess, viz., Larue Daviess' and others, and also, of Robards. For the same reasons the judgment of
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.