Lee's Adm'r v. Harper
Lee's Adm'r v. Harper
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
■ This action was brought by appellant against appellees for a breach of their covenant, wherein they stipulated that if they could not agree amongst themselves as to what damages appellant should
On the trial of the case after it was reversed the first time, numerous instructions were asked by appellant, all of which were overruled, and but two given. The first was to the effect that if .the jury believed from' the evidence that the writing sued on was executed on Sunday, the Christian Sabbath, it was not obligatory, and the jury should find for the defendants. The second stated that if they believed from the evidence that the arbitrators were not sworn-before they entered upon the discharge of their duties, or if, after they made their award, they .failed to give notice thereof to the defendants, in writing, unless they should believe from the evidence that the swearing of the arbitrators and the notification of the defendants were waived by them, they should find for defendants. The judgment was reversed by this court, because the first instruction was given without qualification, and on that ground alone. On the last trial the qualification as suggested by this court, was added to the instruction to the jury on that subject, and was sufficient. Those asked by appellant were properly overruled, certain facts were selected out of the evidence and grouped in them, with the design of giving to these facts especial prominence before the jury, to the obscuration or total eclipse of other proipinent and important facts, a inode constantly disapproved by this court. There is no available error, therefore, found in overruling or giving instructions.
Nor is any error perceived in the rulings of the court on the ad
The question raised by exceptions Nos. 24 and 25 were'not assigned as reasons for a new trial, and are therefore deemed to be waived.
On the whole case the judgment must be affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.