Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1882

Mathis v. Commonwealth

Mathis v. Commonwealth
Court of Appeals of Kentucky · Decided June 24, 1882 · Hines
11 Ky. Op. 686; 4 Ky. L. Rptr. 53; 1882 Ky. LEXIS 266

Mathis v. Commonwealth

Opinion of the Court

Opinion by

Judge Hines :

The indictment charges Fred Mathis and Robert Price with the murder of one Murphy, and alleges that they “did conspire together and willfully, unlawfully and feloniously, with malice aforethought, kill and murder Thomas Murphy.” To the indictment a demurrer was overruled, and on trial of Mathis he was found guity and sentenced to the penitentiary for twelve years. On the trial, Price was offered as a witness for Mathis, but was rejected by the court apparently upon the ground that he was jointly indicted, and the indicement charged a conspiracy. The Crim. Code (1876), § 234, provides that persons jointly indicted may be competent as witnesses for each other, unless the indictment charge a conspiracy. To exclude the witness thus jointly indicted, the indictment must be a good indictment for conspiracy *687at common law, which is clearly not the case here. The charge is of a conspiracy, but what the object of the conspiracy was is not alleged. It is not charged that they conspired to kill Murphy. The conspiracy may have been for any other purpose. The indictment is in this repect defective. The demurrer should ha.ve been sustained.

Wm. Wilson, /. P. Hobson, for appellant. P. W. Hardin, for appellee.

Judgment reversed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.