Prewitt v. Commonwealth
Prewitt v. Commonwealth
Opinion of the Court
Opinion by
The principal, and in fact the only, ground relied on for a reversal of this judgment was the refusal of the court below to grant the appellant a continuance. The appellant having been charged with the crime of rape, the object of a continuance was to enable the accused to show that the prosecuting witness was an unchaste woman.
We have examined the facts of the record with much care, and the testimony relied on for the defense is conclusive as to the guilt of the accused, although the girl of sixteen may have been so depraved as to yield willingly to the lustful desire of the accused. The unfortunate victim of appellant’s brutal passion is shown to have been scarcely sixteen years of age, without friends or family to protect her and so ignorant as rendered her unable to protest against the
This suggestion was made in the presence of his friend, Durbin, and two or three others whose names are connected with the disgraceful affair, and they followed after Prewitt (the accused). When the latter overtook them he stated that his purpose was to arrest them, ’and when Durbin approached he commenced to write on some paper that he had taken from his pocket and the girl began to cry at what was taking place, believing no doubt that her arrest was inevitable. According to the testimony of the defense the parties, Prewitt and Durbin, had an interview with the girl’s lover, and for the promise of ten dollars he agreed if she was willing that she might gratify the desires of the four men at two dollars and fifty cents each, and the girl consenting she was led off to the woods by the accused and there he had sexual intercourse with her, and when she returned his friend Durbin took charge of her and gratified his beastly lust.
This the girl and Devine deny, the girl stating that it was through fear and against her consent that her ruin was accomplished. She swears that this was the first time that she had ever known a man in that way, and in this statement she is sustained by the accused, who in effect boasted of his success in his having been the first man who had carnal knowledge of this unfortunate, ignorant creature. He proves by Durbin, who from his own statement is an expert in such matters, that, from his long experience, the intercourse he had with this girl of sixteen satisfied him that she was quite common, and in the opinion of the two she was so common that Prewitt, the
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.