Court of Appeals of Kentucky, 1886

Fitzsimmons v. Flynn

Fitzsimmons v. Flynn
Court of Appeals of Kentucky · Decided February 25, 1886 · Pryor
13 Ky. Op. 950; 7 Ky. L. Rptr. 606; 1886 Ky. LEXIS 159

Fitzsimmons v. Flynn

Opinion of the Court

Opinion by

Judge Pryor:

It is conceded by the appellant that the deed to the property in controversy was executed to him for the sole purpose of securing a lien on a debt due him by the grantor. This debt is in the nature of an open account, with no written evidence of the indebtedness or any part of it. An absolute conveyance may be shown to be a mortgage; and there is no pretense that a sale was made, or if so the facts not only conduce to show but establish a different state of case. Plere the mortgagor has been in possession since the execution of the deed, for the period of fifteen years, and so far as this record shows is still in the possession. The only claim against the property is the open account that if owing is long since barred by the statutes of limitation. The appellant is asserting a right to the property, and in fact claims to be the owner in fee; and such being the case there is no reason why a bill can not be maintained to quiet the title, or to remove an incumbrance that clouds appellees’ right to the use and enjoyment of the realty.

Judgment is affirmed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.